Advise needed on dealing over price
OOPS! That should have read " I had five offers on the boat all were above that 7% figure and the deals did not proceed for reasons *not* related to price or condition.
I also think that I may have misread the original post. In reading it back it sounds like your broker is telling you what he thinks the boat is worth and you have not really come to a conclusion for yourself. That makes your question especially difficult to answer because with as little information about specifics, it is hard to know what the right answer is here.