On many older boats such hardware was installed by cutting into the section, attaching the hardware and then effecting a gelcoat/FRG repair.
To do the same Id offer that color matching of gel coat and Preval Spray bottles are in your future.
Ref.: Preval Sprayer
How to: Do websearch for: "Gelcoat repair with making a mess" Michigan Fiberglass Gelcoat Repair with John Gabriel