SailNet Community - View Single Post - Help choosing the project and the designer/naval architect.
View Single Post
post #65 of Old 01-13-2014
Senior Member
PCP's Avatar
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Portugal, West Coast
Posts: 16,505
Thanks: 21
Thanked 113 Times in 96 Posts
Rep Power: 13
Re: Help choosing the project and the designer/naval architect.

Originally Posted by grafare View Post
PCP: ....
The Atlantic project is fantastic, but I prefer the 51 instead of the 43 . On the same line, I like the Stadtship 56 Stadtship 56 Oester / K&M Yachtbuilders , designed by Van de Stadt and built by K&M. However, I don’t know if it has the same stability and seaworthiness. I am also into the pilothouse and hard dodger.
I like your design. So far, my list of requirements have the following items (some are also in your list/design):
A strong, fast, comfortable, functional and easily handled boat perfectly suited for both high latitude and tropical sailing. Ideal size, 45-55 ft. She must have 3 berths, to accommodate 6 (4 guests) people. A protected (center) cockpit and hard dodger fixed in plate structure. Unpainted aluminum hull above the waterline, centerboard (or variable bulb), shallow draft, fractional sloop (or cutter) rigged. A deck saloon with good all-round visibility. Good access to engine room. Well-designed stern with dinghy davits and a platform or scoop with a folding or retractable ladder. A larger-than-standard self-draining gas locker with space for additional tanks Retractable bowsprit, quick and easy access to the chain locker with a vertical drop to avoid the chain getting snagged, and a powerful and reliable windlass. A well-planned reefing system with lines led back to the cockpit, ideally to an electric winch. Well designed spaces for electric storage and generation by solar panels and wind. Bigger diesel (close to 1.500 km range) and water tanks. Lightning protection. Mosquito screen. Well insulated with thermo-acoustic protection. Good sailing capabilities in light and upwind. Dedicated workshop/garage. Light interior and decks (no wooden furniture/finishing), with minimum moving parts. Tempered glass windows. Watertight aluminum doors. Power generator. Diesel heater.
In respect to the cost of a NA, could you please give me ballpark figures?
The cost of building and equipping it in Brazil will be gigantic. Brazilian tax system is very complex and sucks. You end up being double taxed on many items. Work force, due to inflation, is currently very expensive. Equipment is imported, so you have to pay 100% taxes (at least) and the markup/service charged by vendor/importer.
The cost of the NA will be the last of your concerns if you are looking at boats like the Stadtship 56 or the Atlantic 51. Those boats will cost over a million and you were talking about 500 000 USD. Besides the VDS 56 is not a stock plan.

Regarding the stock plan you have refereed from Vand de Stadt it is one of the more modern among the ones that they propose (they tend to be all old designs) but the only similitude with the Atlantic is having a lifting keel. The hulls are very different.

Regarding the boat that once I intended to build, more than 10 years ago the estimated price would be around 400 000 euros, including the price of plans. I believe that today it will cost more than the 500 000 USD you have talked about.

More than 10 years ago the price of an Atlantic 43 was about 520 000 euros without VAT. Now it would cost certainly substantially more.

Regarding the price of plans if you are interested you have just to send an email to the NAs with stock planes that interest you, like Vand de Stadt or Dick Zall and ask. Regarding the prices of the plans for the boat that I intended to build, it was more than 10 years ago and I don't remember exactly the prices but I remember that changing the stock plan for what I had designed was not a significant difference, I believe it was something like 2000 euros.

But I have said plans, specially if stock ones are just a small percentage (maybe 5%) of the real cost of the boat. You should focus first on the budget you really have available because unless you can spend 3 times more than the figures you have talked about, considering sophisticated aluminium boats over 50fts or one offs makes no sense. That's all a question of money. If you have enough do just like SVauspicious suggested: Contact a good NA with experience in Aluminium boats and tell him what you want and I am sure he will be able to do it, for about 15% to 20% of the cost of the boat.



To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Last edited by PCP; 01-13-2014 at 07:34 AM.
PCP is offline  
Quote Share with Facebook
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome