View Single Post
  #20 (permalink)  
Old 05-01-2007
Craig Smith's Avatar
Craig Smith Craig Smith is offline
Anchorsmith
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 183
Rep Power: 4
Craig Smith is on a distinguished road
Arrow

Quote:
Originally Posted by jasonr575
Ok this is some good information. The weight is good but my anchor style is bad for the area, is what i am getting from this. Well may be the best course of action is to discuss bottem types in these areas. Anybody familiar with the areas i have mentioned before and their bottems? Then we can pick the best anchor for the combination of areas.
Jason, it should be clear from my affiliation with Rocna what my recommendation would be, so I will avoid making it.

If you do a little more research you will find that newer designs will deal with a combination of bottoms very well. It is not true, as some will suggest, that you need specialist anchors for specific bottoms (although it used to be).

To start you off, you can find the two most comprehensive tests of recent years on our website under "independent reviews" (SAIL and Yachting Monthly) which are up-to-date but focus on hardish sand, so raising the bar a little high in terms of setting ability (you will not likely find the CQR quite as bad as they report, for example ).
Overall comments here.

This is an extensive review of the Delta which is tested in grounds a little farther south than New England, but the bottoms are probably fairly similar: The Delta Anchor- A cruising test report on the Delta anchor
Not a direct comparison with any other types, but since it talks about the CQR you should find it interesting.
__________________
Craig Smith
affiliated with Rocna Anchors
Reply With Quote