SailNet Community - View Single Post - How do you feel about catamarans?
View Single Post
  #135  
Old 03-14-2014
MikeJohns MikeJohns is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Hobart
Posts: 80
Thanks: 4
Thanked 10 Times in 10 Posts
Rep Power: 7
MikeJohns is on a distinguished road
Re: How do you feel about catamarans?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Cruisingdad View Post
ÖÖÖ..Pitch Polling. I don't buy the whole "cat is going to flip" business. I am not saying that is not possible, but come on! We are talking a very rare occurrence. I would love to compare that to the number of monos that hole themselves on a reef due to their draft or the number of broken ribs or serious sea sickness that a mono can give. I think I will take my chances................ Brian

Pitchpoling and inversion occur in heavy weather, they are not common but common enough to start to show some disturbing trends. We should look at why they are not common. For example itís not common for Pedalboats be sunk by North Atlantic winter storms People may choose to believe the risk is low because the frequency of disaster is low. That can give false confidence and lead to poor decisions.

The reason inversion should be treated so seriously is that fatalities from rough weather inversion are very high with catamarans. The hull is untenable as a survival platform and emergency equipment is unreachable. The risk is extreme by any sensible risk assessment.

There is some very poorly informed comment that you can sit on the hull of am inverted cat and wait for rescue . Itís touted as one of the attributes of undamaged cats when comparing them to damaged monohulls ! But not only is that an invalid comparison but itís also not sensible to consider cats as survival platforms in rough seas. There is a very high death rate from inverted catamarans in heavy weather. Thatís due to several major problems with the inverted cat and itís instant transition to a flooded almost completely inaccessible wreck.

It's an alarming emerging trend that the majority of people aboard cats in heavy weather inversions die. The dead are not here to passionately put their side of the story and the living often donít want to know, or want to rationalize the risks away. There is a multihull subculture that refuses to accept that their chosen craft have problems. Problems are due to a particularly bad boat or the fault of the operator.

A comparison of a cat and a mono should consider both price and size. Iíd suggest that a fair comparison for cost and materials is between cat and a monohull thatís at least 10 feet longer on the waterline. So for example compare a 45 foot Cat with a 56 foot mark cruising monohull and then look at stability, comfort, watertight subdivision, passage speed, storage room and the overall feel of the boat as a home. Then start to juggle the other compromises. Youíll find it doesnít matter all that much which boat you chose if they fit the operational area criteria. But you can improve your chances with a good choice that matches your cruising style.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
The Following User Says Thank You to MikeJohns For This Useful Post:
capt vimes (03-14-2014)