Conch Charters BVI
I echo Jim. I have used them twice and will probably use them again. They did seem to be adding some newer boats to their fleet when I was down there a year ago.
One negative is that if you have problems they will want you to get the boat back to on of the anchorages on Tortola. i guess the expensive guys like the Moorings can get to you wherever you are. I ended up doing the repair myself so I would not have to return to Tortola. i did have two great trips with them.