There is no such thing as a dumb question but as many of your fellow members continue to prove there is an endless supply of dumb answers.
Here we go again . . . a poster who only wants answers he likes to hear, all others are "dumb answers".
In contrast to his sometimes condescending style, Giulietta is perhaps the most knowledgable sailor on these forums. He was sincerely offering his POV based upon your extremely non-specific question. IMHO, calling anyone's response dumb will certainly earn you no respect.