As was mentioned, some form of indexing, or cross reference system certainly needs to be co-ordinated. Perhaps if a forum format is decided, it could be set up with categories, so relevant reviews and articles could be initially posted in order by the author.
Otherwise CD (it is his brainchild) would need to do some regular organizing to avoid the need for inquiring sailors to sift through pages and pages of random reviews . . . just to find recommendations for say, the best bilge vermin eradicator.
True Blue . . .
sold the Nauticat