SailNet Community - View Single Post - utm vs lat/long
Thread: utm vs lat/long
View Single Post
post #3 of Old 11-26-2003
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 155
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Rep Power: 14
utm vs lat/long

Lat Long is a universal measurement of earth coordinates, in theory independent of map projection. A map projection (e.g. UTM, Albers Equal Area, etc) is a method of mapping the ellipsoid onto a flat surface. THere are probably 20 map projections in common use. Every mapping introduces distortions. Different kinds of distortions are present in the different projections. But all representations of the surface of the ellipsoid earth onto a flat surface will be distorted somewhere. Some distort angles, some areas, some distances. We have all seen the massive size of Greenland in grade school representations of the earth on a Mercator projection. For UTM, within a zone, the Northing and Easting coordinates are X-Y coordinates and can be used to make distance measurements, area measurements, and even direction measurements--all with some measure of inaccuracy and distortion. Going between zones is worse.
Lat Long is ideal for taking sights, etc (with a sextant). If you know very well what you are doing, the inaccuracies in a standard map projection are intended to be insignificant for normal use of the map.
Mathematical transformation between lat long and any map projection typically requires only the two axes of the earth as input--yes the two axes are different. Also, since the earth size has been measured many times, with different answers each time, you have to select the model of the earth ellipsoid you wish to use. Then the math transformation is trivial.
Normally N,E,Z are easier to scale off large scale topo maps, and if you have a handy computer, then transform to lat long or any other projection of interest.
All this said, I have seen the projection coordinates more often used in land mapping or map transformations for spacecraft imagery or high-altitude plane photo mapping, than for anything marine. If I were doing it, I''d stick with the standard marine stuff.
mcain is offline  
Quote Share with Facebook
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome