Here's Chesapeake Bay Magazine 2010 Best of the Bay restaurant list. I can't vouch for all of them as I haven't been to them all.
Best Restaurants for Crabcakes
Chick & Ruth's (Annapolis, Md.)
Smithfield Station (Smithfield, Va.)
Annie's (Kent Narrows)
Skipper's Pier (Deale, Md.)
Captain's Table (Solomons, Md.)
Ken's Back Porch Cafe (Annapolis, Md.)
Muskrat Alley (Rock Hall, Md.)
The Inn at Pirates Cove (Galesville, Md.)
Boatyard Bar &
Grill (Annapolis, Md.)
Best Restaurants for Steamed Crabs
Cantler's Riverside Inn (Annapolis, Md.)
The Crab Claw (St. Michaels, Md.)
Waterman's Crab House (Rock Hall, Md.)
Harris Crab House (Kent Narrows)
Mike's Crab House (Riva, Md.)
Skipper's Pier (Deale, Md.)
Harrison's Chesapeake House (Tilghman, Md.)
Stoney's Seafood House (Broomes Island and Solomons, Md.)
Kentmoor Restaurant (Kent Island)
Best Restaurants for Maryland Crab Soup
Cantler's Riverside Inn (Annapolis, Md.)
The Crab Claw (St. Michaels, Md.)
Waterman's Crab House (Rock Hall, Md.)
Davis' Pub (Annapolis, Md.)
Harbor Shack (Rock Hall, Md.)
Carrol's Creek Cafe (Annapolis, Md.)
Harris Crab House (Kent Narrows)
Stoney's Seafood House (Broomes Island and Solomons, Md.)
Fisherman's Inn & Crab Deck (Kent Narrows)
Kentmoor (Kent Island)
Woody's Crab House (Northeast, Md.)
Best Restaurants for Cream of Crab Soup
The Narrows (Kent Narrows)
Carrol's Creek Cafe (Annapolis, Md.)
Smithfield Station (Smithfield, Va.)
Annie's (Kent Narrows)
Cantler's Riverside Inn (Annapolis, Md.)
Harris Crab House (Kent Narrows)
Harbor Shack (Rock Hall, Md.)
The Inn at Pirates Cove (Galesville, Md.)
Surf Rider (Hampton, Va.)
Thursday's (Galesville, Md.)
Mango's (Herrington Harbour South)
Waterman's Crab House (Rock Hall, Md.)
Best Restaurants for Oysters
Cantler's Riverside Inn (Annapolis, Md.)
McGarvey's (Annapolis, Md.)
Surf Rider (Hampton, Va.)
The Crab Claw (St. Michaels, Md.)
Skipper's Pier (Deale, Md.)
Harbor Shack (Rock Hall, Md.)
Harrison's Chesapeake House (Tilghman, Md.)
Middleton's Tavern (Annapolis, Md.)
Best Restaurants for Burgers
Harbor Shack (Rock Hall, Md.)
Davis' Pub (Annapolis, Md.)
Smithfield Station (Smithfield, Va.)
Surf Rider (Hampton, Va.)
Boatyard Bar &
Grill (Annapolis, Md.)
The Galley (Deltaville, Va.)
McGarvey's (Annapolis, Md.)
Best Restaurants for the View
The Chart House (Annapolis, Md.)
Smithfield Station (Smithfield, Va.)
Hemingway's (Kent Island)
Waterman's Crab House (Rock Hall, Md.)
Harbor Shack (Rock Hall, Md.)
The Crab Claw (St. Michaels, Md.)
Mears Great Oak Landing (Fairlee Creek)
Surf Rider (Hampton, Va.)
Carrol's Creek Cafe (Annapolis, Md.)
Skipper's Pier (Deale, Md.)
Stoney's Solomons Pier (Solomons, Md.)
Best Dockside Bars
Red Eye's Dock Bar (Kent Narrows)
Pusser's (Annapolis, Md.)
Harbor Shack (Rock Hall, Md.)
Tiki Bar (Solomons, Md.)
Jellyfish Joel's (Mears Great Oak Landing)
Mango's (Herrington Harbour South)
The Jetty (Kent Narrows)