SailNet Community - View Single Post - Choosing a buyer's broker
View Single Post
Old 05-28-2010
sailingfool sailingfool is offline
ASA and PSIA Instructor
Join Date: Apr 2000
Posts: 3,509
Thanks: 7
Thanked 19 Times in 19 Posts
Rep Power: 15
sailingfool will become famous soon enough
Originally Posted by dschwenk View Post
Yes. We enter into an attorney client relationship with our clients. Attendant to that are all of our obligations of confidentiality, competence, lack of conflicts, etc. that go with being a lawyer. In some cases we charge our clients up front and refund those fees out of the transaction, in some cases accept the work on the eventual broker's fee.

And not to quibble (but being a lawyer its hard for me to help it), I understand your argument that if the broker's fee comes out of the seller's column on the closing sheet, then that means that the seller is paying. But at least in my line of work, there are lots of examples where one person pays and another person is the client. This happens in contingent cases (if the Defendant pays, then the plaintiff and attorney get paid) in divorce cases (if a parent pays for a child or if one of the two parties has all the money) in criminal cases (parent/friend/relative puts up the money), etc. It is up to the thoughtful, ethical and smart to be able to separate where the fee is coming from the question of who is owed the duty of care. I will readily agree with you, however, that there are many, many, many examples of situations in which this line was not properly drawn and that the power of money can corrupt this thinking.

Dirk Schwenk
Baylaw, LLC
So in net, if you provide a broker's services, you do so with the same compensation and contractual arrangements as ALL the other brokers in the USA, so you are a "buyer's" broker in spirit only.

So should you participate in a yacht sale to a "customer", will you have your customer sign one of those forms where they acknowledge you are acting as an agent of the seller?

You may have great intentions for the buyer and as much as I LIKE the concept of a buyer's broker, this seems like a lot of mumble-jumbo for an underlying broker-business-as-usual, (which is not a bad long as everyone understands who is in whose corner...).
__________________ several regards...

Last edited by sailingfool; 05-28-2010 at 03:53 PM.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook