RIB vs Rigid with collar
Bought a real RIB summer before last after struggling with an older rigid boat with collar (Walker Bay) for a year. Although the Walker Bay was easy to use, it felt VERY uncomfortable in rough seas, or even heavy chop, and rocked much more than a true RIB.
I choose the Brigg model over several other and have been very happy with my choice, but it all comes down to need and preference. I really wanted a fiberglass bottom, not plastic, and was willing to forgo the convenience of a folding bottom for the stability under speed and comfort of a solid v-hull. I am glad for the slightly heavier weight when the water gets rough or the ride is long.
As stated many times above, it all depends on your intended use. I really enjoyed the Walker Bay in the marina for short trips, playing in the sun, or ease of use for kids.
Saginaw Bay, Michigan
"The pessimist complains about the wind; the optimist expects it to change; the realist adjusts the sails." - William Arthur Ward