SailNet Community - View Single Post - C&C 29 Mk II Vs. Beneteau First 28.5/29
View Single Post
  #2  
Old 01-30-2011
hangupndrive hangupndrive is offline
Member
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Seattle
Posts: 78
Thanks: 4
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Rep Power: 8
hangupndrive is on a distinguished road
Hi Michael-

I do not have direct experience sailing either of these boats. I have, however inspected (for possible purchase) the C&C 29 and I have read quite a bit about the Beneteau as well as talked with one owner. I like both boats and would have considered owning either of them.

I own a '88 C&C 30 MkII just so you know my bias.

I think the constructions and materials of the C&C are superior to the beneteau. I prefer the keel stepped mast of the C&C to the deck stepped of the beneteau. The C&C is going to have an end-grain balsa cored deck vs. plywood for the Beneteau. C&C will have a lead keel. Not sure about the Beneteau but they are more of a production-line boat so Iron would not surprise me. The C&C is a few years older (early 80's vs. late 80's) but assuming similar condition, I'd take the C&C. One possibibility that exists with the benneteau and not the C&C is trailerability. If you get the shoal draft with the wing-keel, it is entirely doable assuming an appropriate tow-vehicle. I had a nice chat with a fellow from California who towed his Beneteay 28 to the Gulf Islands for the Summer.

Also look around for a Cal 28 or a Tartan T 2800. Or, more expensive $35-$40k US, A J28.

The prices you are seeing seem way high. I know things cost more in Canada. Why, I have no idea. If you extend your search to the US, you should see both boats, depending on condition, well under $30,000 US. I hope this helps. If you're from Great-Lakes Canada, there seems to be a lot in Michigan, Chicago, Ohio for sale.

Good Luck

Doug Powers
Totoro
C&C 30 MkII
Seattle, WA
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook