As we sit with our charts and notepad in front of us, I think we've been coming to the same conclusions you have. Antingua is probably out of the question. The problem then is, what do we do? We want to spend at least 6 hours a day sailing (say 8am to 2pm) at least. But most of islands are too close to each other to do that. I guess we can always lap the islands before setting in. Or kick back with a few PainKillers on the beaches.
Thanks for the posts. We appreciate the feedback.