Eastern Long Island
A suggestion from James Kidd, another local sailor:
"This past weekend I came across a secret (I guess, not anymore) gem…
In West Neck Harbor, located on the Southern tip of Shelter Island (just west of the south ferry) there is a small marina that has restored an old wooden sailboat and converted it into an outside bar, complete with raw bar (great oysters) and appetizers.
The best bet is to anchor in the shallow harbor and take your dinghy in for a cold one, and a dozen oysters…."