SailNet Community - View Single Post - Riddles with a Prize, by Mantus Anchors
 View Single Post
Old 11-21-2012
JulieMor
Senior Member

Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 853
Thanks: 47
Thanked 16 Times in 16 Posts
Rep Power: 6

Re: Riddles with a Prize, by Mantus Anchors

If the weight of the spring is negligible, yet by pushing the head down the spring causes the head to pop up, the weight of the head has to be negligible. Both now have to be nearly the same weight if the head was pushed down to completely compress the spring. And there's the big unknown. How far does the spring have to be compressed to cause the head to pop up? Of course you have to define the word "pop" when using it here. Does that mean pop up like a jack in the box, or does it merely mean making the head rise back up, regardless how quickly?

For the box to be lifted, enough force has to be created through the compression of the spring to cause both the head and the box to be lifted off the surface the box is sitting on. The force of the spring pushes the head upward at a velocity sufficient enough to stretch the spring beyond it's natural state and in doing so create sufficient stretch in the spring that the box will be lifted off the surface before the velocity of the head stops and begins to succumb to gravity and the forces of the spring returning to its natural state.

Since the spring's weight in negligible, the weight of the box and the head would have to be negligible, barring any super-spring, space-age steel that the spring might be composed of.

The weight of all three would have to be negligible relative to the weight of any two, in other words, all are almost zero. Unless you state the head compressed the spring half way to cause it to pop up like a jack in the box, which would allow you to surmise that fully compressing the spring could cause the spring to decompress at such a rate as to lift the box off the surface as described above.

This is an answer that could be theorized in a calculus equation but I forgot most of the calculus symbols. It's been a while.
JulieMor is offline