Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: CT/ Long Island Sound
Thanked 39 Times in 38 Posts
Rep Power: 17
Re: Sailnet Suggestion Box
It's starting again. Too many subfora, subgroups, sub-discussions. Billyruffian just had an interesting post about a close quarters encounter with a ferry. Many people can identify with that situation. He posted it in "vessels in danger", wondering if it was the right category, since his boat wasn't really in danger. As some above have mentioned, if the forum is split out into monohulls vs catamarans vs trimarans, and then further into specific brands of each of them, it stops being a forum, traffic drops, and it dies. Splitting off every possible variant defeats the purpose of the site. I have a diesel engine, so diesel issues are of potential interest. If the diesel postings are split out between Volvo, Westerbeke, Cummins, Detroit, Faryman and Yamar, I am not going to search through each sub-site to see if the question raised might pertain to me as well. If all the questions are funneled onto an "Auxiliary Engines" section, I am more likely to check it out, and possibly respond to posters -- even if I don't have the same brand as them. That is what a forum is supposed to do: create a nexus of communication to help solve problems. In another example, lots of people have had their children on their boats, and know various ways to keep them safe, occupied and happy. Their children are grown now, so they never look at the separate subsection on sailing with children. This deprives the forum of the insights that might come out if the issues were posted in the "general" section, where they'd be seen by more people. Arguments that Sailnetters set their computers to simply show any new posts, regardless of the topic, are leaky in my book. If someone has a question about sail trim and posts the same thing in "general" and in "racing", which will be answered first and have the most replies? Instead of trying to divide up all the topics into little tiny boxes that provide responses from a few like-minded souls, why not generalize as much as possible so as to get the most varied possible exchange of ideas about sailing? That way we all benefit.