
12-14-2009
|
|
Senior Member
|
|
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: VA
Posts: 1,692
Rep Power: 7
|
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Faster
In general I think the C34 (and/or the 36) are very nice coastal cruising boats. In both models, though, the MKII improvements are significant both in terms of aesthetics and function. Bigger engines, larger cockpits, walkthru transoms are among the improvements.
Unfortunately the MKIIs are also often listing at near twice the price... so your budget will have a large bearing here.
|
I disagree that the changes on the MKII make it a "better" boat. They make it a "different" boat but not necessarily a better boat.
My 1991 C36 has the walk through transom so I give up nothing there. However, my boat retains the narrower stern which looks better to me. (though the Admiral does like the MKII aft cabin). I also have a reasonably sized, forward facing nav station which I prefer. The last couple of years of MKI's changed to a outward facing, smaller nav station to allow for a door to the "aft cabin" and I think that follows through on the MKII's. I think it was wasted space on the MKI's and not at all an improvement. On the MKII's its that huge aft cabin that dictates the wide stern, which does nothing to make the boat a better sailer or more attractive to the eye for many people.
I also, don't have portlights through the hull, so that's one leak I'll never worry about. I do have darker teak below than the newer models, but I actually prefer it, however its a purely aesthetic preference.
Both models are designed for easy owner maintenance and are great boats for coastal cruising or day sailing with a family or friends. The changes to the C34 MKI's series took place about the same time (1990 or so) before the MKII's came out so there are C34 MKI's with walk through transoms if thats what you want.
__________________
PalmettoSailor (formerly midlifesailor)
s/v Palmetto Moon
1991 Catalina 36
|