SailNet Community

SailNet Community (http://www.sailnet.com/forums/)
-   Boat Review and Purchase Forum (http://www.sailnet.com/forums/boat-review-purchase-forum/)
-   -   Ericson 25 vs Catalina 25 (http://www.sailnet.com/forums/boat-review-purchase-forum/56160-ericson-25-vs-catalina-25-a.html)

jephotog 07-13-2009 12:58 PM

Ericson 25 vs Catalina 25
 
In my search for a boat I have narrowed it down to two boats a C25 and E25. I have gotten some basic information from the Catalina and Ericson owners sites. But figure their opinions are biased. I am looking for a group of people to put this in perspective.

I looked at a C25 this weekend and although not able to see inside it looked clean outside with 4 cockpit winches and spinnaker rigging. It looks overall clean even though it has not been registered since 04. The owner has moved out of state so it is hard to arrange a viewing.

I have also been talking with an Ericson 25 owner waiting on photos and hope to look at that boat this week or weekend.

The Catalina is a 83' C25 fixed keel with a 2 cycle 7.5 HP, looks clean and ready to sail.

The Ericson is a 74' E25 with a 4 cycle 7.5 short shaft Mecury OB with alternator. It has a keel C/B configuration. It has been used minimally for the last decade. The owners live in the mountains and have a Montgomery 17.

I figure I can get them both for around $4000. The Ericson probably needs a little bit more work to get in the water. I think the Catalina would be a good boat for our needs but I have always liked Ericson boats.

Ericson Pros.
  • Better Built ?
  • Easier to Launch
  • New Main
  • 4 Stroke engine (need to add long shaft)
  • More Sails (New Main)
Catalina Pros
  • Newer
  • Faster
  • More parts available
  • Closer to splashing.
I would appreciate any thoughts and input comparing these two boats.

Thanks
Jordan

jephotog 07-13-2009 10:46 PM

How about Keel C-B design
 
Okay how about just some comments on the Keel C-B design on the Ericson?

I would appreciate any input on this design. Others I have seen have actually had stub keels. The Ericson 25 seems to have a lead bottom without any keel looking appendage, but a centerboard for windward performance. Any care to comment on this design?

Thanks

JimB517 07-14-2009 08:12 PM

catalina 25
 
Hi, I've sailed my 1978 Catalina 25 fin keel all over Southern CA and Mexico. I've sailed 2000 miles per year for the last 4 years. I've raced Newport - Ensenada, Crew of Two Around Catalina and the Border Run. I've single handed from San Diego around the Channel Islands 3 times and down Baja once. Nothing major has ever broken. Good boat, simple boat, solid boat. Parts available. Great owners group. Easy to find new or used sails - generally off the shelf. Factory support. There are some known weaknesses (like leaky windows on the old boats) to the Cat 25 but the owners group will tell you how to deal with them. Come to our owners group web site and download the guide to self-apprasing the Catalina 25 and do your own mini-survey before making an offer and doing a sea trial/survey.

You say the C25 is a fin keel and while it can be trailered, it is not really intended to be loaded and unloaded often. If you have to trailer, look for a swing keel or a newer wing keel.

jephotog 07-14-2009 11:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JimB517 (Post 505367)
You say the C25 is a fin keel and while it can be trailered, it is not really intended to be loaded and unloaded often. If you have to trailer, look for a swing keel or a newer wing keel.

Thanks Jim,
I know the C25 is a very capable boat, and I have been to the site and downloaded the self appraisal information. What I would really like is the performance and reliability of a fin keel with the trailerability of a swing keel. The wing keel era boats are out of my price range. I would love to do some racing on my boat but any boat in my price range would not be race ready. I will have to stick with abusing OPBs.

I do not intend this boat to be a trailer sailor, it will live in a marina. Besides as a second home in town here and a daysailor and weekender, I would love to be able to be able to put the miles in you do and take a few trips like you describe on the coast, Baja, Lake Mead. That's why a trailer is important. A swing keel would open up my launching options but limit my performance. I am also leary of the stability of a swing keel design compared to a fixed keel, even though there are no s/k C25s nearby. That is why the E25s are being considered.

Funny story thought I have been searching for PHRF information on these boats and have not been able to find a location with both boats to get a good comparison. But just found a thread just now, in which you had contributed on the C25 site with this link.
http://offshore.ussailing.org/Assets...0Handicaps.pdf
Very good information. I see the PHRF on all configurations of these boats to be within about 10 PHRF points of each other, so that is less of a consideration than I had estimated it would be.

One thing the C25 has going for it though is space. Room for 2 in the v-berth and aft berth, and larger cockpit, all of which is nice for entertaining and sharing a cruise with friends. It may be tight but can't imagine many other 25 footers that could be more comfortable for 2 couples for the weekend. I met a family of 5 that spends every weekend on theirs in the Great Salt Lake.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:01 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.1
(c) Marine.com LLC 2000-2012