SailNet Community

SailNet Community (http://www.sailnet.com/forums/)
-   Boat Review and Purchase Forum (http://www.sailnet.com/forums/boat-review-purchase-forum/)
-   -   Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32 (http://www.sailnet.com/forums/boat-review-purchase-forum/93117-catalina-27-pearson-28-ericson-32-a.html)

catch22 10-15-2012 03:24 PM

Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
I've spent a decade sailing/racing my Catalina 22. It's time to move to something bigger.

I'm looking at the following boats that are in my price range:
1976 Catalina 27
1977 Pearson 28-1
1970 Ericson 32

All three boats have Atomic 4's.

I sail in the Western Basin of Lake Erie where the water can get a little thin at times.

Wife and I will be switching from racing/day sailing to more cruising/racing. I'd still like to compete in several regattas per year. We'll probably take a couple long weekend cruises per year. More after we retire in the next five years.

Would appreciate any insight and advice.

daledog 10-15-2012 03:37 PM

Re: Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
Sail a Cal. Cal 29 or for racing sail a Cal 9.2

jsaronson 10-15-2012 04:55 PM

Re: Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
Owned a Pearson 28-1. Great boat, will outsail the Catalina and is roomier. Bottom line with any boat of this vintage - condition is more important than pedigree. Good luck!

SlowButSteady 10-15-2012 05:46 PM

Re: Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by daledog (Post 933950)
Sail a Cal. Cal 29 or for racing sail a Cal 9.2

Or a Cal 2-27; and look for a boat with a diesel.

daledog 10-15-2012 05:52 PM

Re: Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
Yeah...another great design. I have an original Cal 27 (pop top) here I'm going to get ship shape to sell this winter. We actually have two, I'm taking the good from both to make a good one. Anyone wants this boat let me know....very sound deck, hull is a Cal! (Hand laid up, solid)...

flo617 10-15-2012 07:00 PM

Re: Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
I don't know much about each sailboat's characteristics but I find the Ericson 32 to have nice lines. And they have good reputation in terms of construction too.

Diesel is definitely a piece of mind. When you replace a fuel filter and under-tighten the hoses by mistake and fuel starts leaking into the bilge, you'll feel better knowing it's diesel.

paul323 10-15-2012 08:03 PM

Re: Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
As always, much depends on how well they have been maintained, and how well equipped they are. And only then which one you like the looks of best :-). Start off by looking at the boat as a collection of parts - how many sails do they have? Engine hours? Age of rigging? Electronics and electricals (e.g. a friend just bought an Islander 28, and had to rewire it). Check out the bilge and keel bolts - look out for any big-ticket problems. Larger boats like these are a lot more complex, with more parts...how much will each boat part you to replace/upgrade?

It's tough to rank a 28' against a 32'; those few feet make a huge difference in size - and often in slip fees and maintenance costs!

Both Pearson and Ericson are well-made boats, solid. Tough to choose between those two. Although smaller, the Pearson feels surprisingly roomy. Smaller and younger vs. bigger and older....tough. Condition and parts decides that.

Catalina's are still made, so parts are still available; as you know they have a huge following. You get a lot of boat for the money with a Catalina, but they IMHO they tend not to be as strongly built, and so if well maintained, fine; if neglected, may take more effort to "bring back". That, and the fact it is smallest, would put it third for me.

blt2ski 10-15-2012 08:53 PM

Re: Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
My boat is a tad bigger than a C27, in line with a C28mkII, and probably a pearson 28. If you like tight spaces, great. If not, go with the E32 or equal length boat, assuming reasonably maintained. It will also be the faster and probably better sailing of the three!

Marty

RobGallagher 10-15-2012 09:33 PM

Re: Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
All three are decent boats. Get the boat in the best overall condition for the money.
Don't be afraid of the A-4, it's a great engine if it and the fuel system are well maintained.

If it's a tie, I would choose;
1. Ericson
2. Pearson
3. Catalina

One of the main reasons that the Catalina comes last is that it's the smallest of the three and the newest.... why would I put the newest last... you might ask... because as the years went on the steel mix used to cast the A-4 block and head decreased in quality. That is why you sometimes find engines from the sixties to early seventies still going strong even though they are salt water cooled and engines from the late seventies+ that have issues.

JMHO, whatever that's worth.

mikel1 10-15-2012 10:30 PM

Re: Catalina 27 or Pearson 28 or Ericson 32
 
I'd go Ericson . . . check out ericsonyachts.org great group and a list connection of Ericsons for sale . . .


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 04:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.1
(c) Marine.com LLC 2000-2012