Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Seattle, WA
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Rep Power: 0
Hood 38 or Tartan 42?
Sorry for the mostly duplicate post from another forum, but looking for all the information I can gather.
I've been on and off the site for several years. After many delays in retirement, I hope to start the transition to cruising over the next two years. With that, it's time to buy the boat.
Briefly, the plan is to spend a couple years exploring the PNW part time before heading south to Mexico, Central America, into Carib., and maybe eventually to Med. The dream has shifted from crossing the Pacific to maybe crossing or shipping across Atlantic. I also dive and am just over 6'2", so a bit of space is nice. So with that much background ...
I am currently looking at a Wauquiez Hood 38 Mk I and a Tartan 42. The boats are both different and similar. Close to same displacement, same "Swan" style hatch, same layout even with area behind companionway. The Tartan is a moderate IOR design with Scheel keel. The Hood is a bit fuller on the ends with centerboard. I've searched the threads and internet, read posts, but finally giving in to just asking if anyone has been on both, either, or has thoughts?
Big unknowns on the Tartan are just how comfortable can an IOR boat be to sail, and is 41 hp really enough power for a 22,000 boat? And on the Hood, how well can she really sail or will pointing and acceleration be issues? They both have decent Comfort ratings though my guess is the Hood is smoother. PHRF on the Tartan is around 120, the Hood varies a lot, but seems to average 141.
The T-42 also comes with an older Selden in-mast furler. I'm thinking that will have to be replaced or modified for a standard mainsail. I've heard it may be possible to modify with a Strong Track or battcar system, but as I've never even considered in mast furling, my knowledge base is close to zero.
Any advice is most welcome.
"You've come to the wrong shop for anarchy ..." ~ Master and Commander