SailNet Community

SailNet Community (http://www.sailnet.com/forums/)
-   Electrical Systems (http://www.sailnet.com/forums/electrical-systems/)
-   -   Using a spare zinc to test a bonding system (http://www.sailnet.com/forums/electrical-systems/97186-using-spare-zinc-test-bonding-system.html)

AnnapolisStar 03-02-2013 04:00 PM

Using a spare zinc to test a bonding system
 
Nigel Calder has a nice procedure on Pg 149 of the Boat Owners Mechanical and Electrical Manual to test the bonding of a boat that would be nice to do periodically. He recommends dipping a silver-silver chloride half cell over board and measuring the voltage between it and any of the underwater bonded metal parts. The voltage of all the underwater pieces of metal when compared to the half cell he says should be the same and greater than 0.2volts.

Why can't I just use a spare zinc, which we all have on board, as the half cell and drop it in the water close to the metal to be tested. The voltage between it and any piece of underwater metal connected to the bonding system should be 0 volts - since the test zinc should be at the same voltage as the zinc connected to the bonding system and protecting the boat. Incidentally if you use a spare zinc as the test cell this procedure will also tell you when its time to change the boat zinc - i.e. whenever the voltage rises above 0.1 volts.

I believe Nigels procedure should be modified at any rate to place the half cell close to the metal to be tested. I believe also that his 0.2 volts is in error and should be modified to -0.98 volts which is the voltage of zinc relative to silver-silver Chloride since all the bonded metal parts should be at boat zinc potential.

Along with the bonding system test Nigel also includes a test for DC leakage (on Pg 149) which could save your life some day but I think it would be more convenient to do this test with your spare zinc if it would work.

Any comments

davidpm 03-02-2013 11:41 PM

Re: Using a spare zinc to test a bonding system
 
Send Nigel and email with your suggestion.
A few years ago I found what I thought was an error in one of his books.
He wrote back and agreed with me and updated the procedure in newer editions.

He seems to follow his readers comments.

And be sure to report back here.

ShipShape 03-27-2013 11:42 PM

Re: Using a spare zinc to test a bonding system
 
1 Attachment(s)
AnnapolisStar, you must have an older edition of Nigel Calder's book, I've got the third edition and it is correct; his procedure for testing the integrity of bonding circuits is on p. 218, and there is a comprehensive test on p. 234. Page 216 is about sizing zincs for your boat and should be read. Actually, the entire chapter is well worth reading. Heck, just read the whole book.

You are correct that a zinc can be used as a reference cell! But cathodic protection systems use zinc (or aluminum or magnesium) anodes to purposely generate a current - the forced current protects your boat's metals by causing the anode to deteriorate instead. A reference cell allows you to measure the voltage between your protective anodes and underwater metals because there is current flowing through the water between them.

Zinc makes a very convenient reference cell since the table for an Ag/AgCl reference cell can be used, just add 1 to get the zinc reference cell value. The third edition of the Boatowner's Mechanical and Electrical Manual has a table of the Galvanic Series of Metals in Seawater on p. 199. From the table, the "natural" voltage of an electrically isolated bronze thruhull as measured with a Ag/AgCl reference cell should be around -0.3 V; with a Zn reference cell: -0.3 + 1 = 0.7 V.

Using my fiberglass boat as a real example, with an Ag/AgCl reference cell my hull potential (and every bonded underwater metal) in seawater is -0.96 V. Using the Zn reference cell in my picture below everything measures 0.09 V.

Remember, that table has values for SEAwater, if you are in brackish of fresh water the values will be different - Google for the appropriate table ... and notice the relative reference cell - there are several types!

I made my reference cell with an engine pencil zinc. You need a good connection between your wire and the zinc so drill as small a hole as possible to fit the (stripped) wire into the hole. For this one I drilled almost 0.75" deep, and slathered the wire with an anti-corrosive conductive paste before cramming it in the hole.

The wire is held to the zinc with "Rescue Tape", which also does a perfect job of keeping the connection dry. You can put a meter jack on the other end, or crimp on an alligator clip such as those in the picture, and clip that onto your meter's probe. Be sure you have very good connections to keep resistance to a minimum as you are measuring very small voltages.

Attachment 13726

In salt water you could measure the whole boat by positioning an Ag/AgCl reference cell amidships about two feet below the surface, but fresh water is not very conductive so it needs to be within a foot of the metal being measured in fresh water. In salt water, a zinc reference cell needs to be within a foot or so of the metal being measured, I do not remember if it will work in fresh water.

kellysails 03-29-2013 01:25 PM

Re: Using a spare zinc to test a bonding system
 
I have the one from boatzincs.com. Works well enough, and overpriced IMHO.

http://i1278.photobucket.com/albums/...ps52127ddf.jpg


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:42 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.1
(c) Marine.com LLC 2000-2012