Old as Dirt!
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Tampa Bay Area
Thanked 139 Times in 132 Posts
Rep Power: 8
Re: Inspecting fire extinguishers
Sound's like you've been down the road that I'm on. I know that I'm going to have to comply with this because it's on the survey and insurance companies don't like interpretation, explanations or ambiguity. They like paper trails and compliance and such.
I may call up the surveyors at some point and have them come do a post-compliance inspection which I will send to insurance. Perhaps they'd be willing to modify their language so that it covers the safety aspects they feel are important, but isn't overly onerous on me.
I can see for example, that the recommendation to tag all extinguishers punishes you for carrying more than is required. How about a recommendation to inspect the USCG minimum and if I carry more I get bonus points??
I can also see your problem of the "uninspectable" extinguishers. Perhaps in my letter of compliance to the insurance company I will tell them I have replaced the current extinguishers with ones that don't require inspection. We'll see..... I DO plan to replace the 2x 10lb dry chem extinguishers on the boat. They're huge and heavy and that's a LOT of dry chemical. I'd much rather have more smaller bottles of clean agent extinguishers.
I cannot offer more than my own experience over 50+ years, for what that's worth. Currently, the most effective means of fire fighting aboard a yacht are first, the fire blanket, then Halon (although that's now evidently against EPA Regulations) and its alternative variants Halotron et al
in engine spaces and, finally, CO2 extinguishers. Despite representations to the contrary, unless one uses and extraordinary amount of CO2, the material does not, in and of itself, represent a health threat, at least not in comparison with a fire, but it is extraordinarily effective in most cases. The other extinguishers are, for the most part, little better than certificate candidates. If it's insurance certificates you're worried about, by all means carry the ABC Extinguishers which might help in the event. If you want to protect and potentially save your boat in extremis, however, have Halotron dispensers in you engine spaces and Fire Blankets and CO2 Canisters handy in your living spaces.
"It is not so much for its beauty that the sea makes a claim upon men's hearts, as for that subtle something, that quality of air, that emanation from the waves, that so wonderfully renews a weary spirit."
Last edited by svHyLyte; 08-22-2014 at 07:18 AM.
Reason: Correct typo and add addendum