SailNet is a forum community dedicated to Sailing enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about sailing, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, repairs, reviews, maintenance, and more!
replacing the stove: alcohol converted to kerosene?
On the refit or replace list for my T30 project is the origo alcohol. It's badly corroded around the burners and is in pretty poor shape. I'm a very avid cook so a good stove is vital to me. I've heard of kerosene refit kits but haven't had any look finding them. I've also been considering a used kerosene stove as I've been told that "there are loads of them out there now that everyone is using propane". Haven't been able to fine any online... I don't want to use propane due to space/cost restraints and I really don't have a problem with kerosene (I've used primus stoves for back packing). Anyone have any advice or sources for me?
It's true that any marine recycle or consignment store is likely to have a good stock of these old stoves, because, indeed, most of us are onto propane. Unfortunately many of them are not in great shape, but they are very inexpensive so you could probably buy a couple and cobble together one good one!
After living (relatively happily) with an alcohol stove for over 10 yrs we have switched to propane, and honestly wouldn't go back.
The lack of preheating & pumping is too convenient, and the price of quality alcohol for the stove was outstripping the cost of beer!!(well.....almost)
Kerosene is an attractive alternate to alcohol because it has a higher heating value and is available in many places (as "paraffin"), perhaps at a lower price. The flame is also more visible.
The down side to kerosene is a distinctive odor and the same old preheating routine that you learned to love with alcohol.
Good question - worthy of a debate.
Remember the reported CO poisoning deaths, resulting from those portable kerosine space heaters, popular during the '70s oil crisis? For years now, the use of kerosine heaters in home sleeping areas has been prohibited in most (if not all) US states.
I would think that boaters are more at risk of CO poisoning due to the confined areas of most boats. I would also be especially concerned with kerosine in cooktops - since galleys of smaller to mid-size boats, normally have no fume extraction equipment.
CO poisoning and CO2 asphyxiation can occur anytime there is an unvented appliance in use in a closed space. That is why there are laws and regulations that prohibit unvented heaters in residences.
Safe use of an unvented appliance (Many are in use in construction projects every winter.)requires a fair amount of ventilation through the walls of the structure to maintain oxygen supply by free communication with outside air.
The cooking stove in a boat is an unvented appliance, whether it is fuelled by alcohol, kerosene, gasoline, LPG, or wood. These flames are small and intermittent, and boats are, generally, quite well ventilated, but it is still good practice to keep some vents open just in case.
CO is the byproduct of any inefficient oxygen/fuel combustion. Back to the question though, has anyone converted their alcohol stoves to kerosene. They seem similar so maybe I could just convert the jets?
I have an old pressure alcohol stove and pressure tank that I would like to part with. It has two burners and an oven. It has a coppertone-ish enamel finsh that is slightly cosemtically challenged, but it was working fine when I took it out of my last boat. I replaced it with stainless steel pressure alcohol stove that looked really nice. I'm in the general northern VA - DC - Annapolis area.
BTW, the current boat has propane, which has its own pros and cons. One fuel will burn you - the other will blow you up. Pick your poison and take appropriate precautions.
CO is the byproduct of any inefficient oxygen/fuel combustion. Back to the question though, has anyone converted their alcohol stoves to kerosene. They seem similar so maybe I could just convert the jets?
Sorry, Dave, these threads do seem to wander, don't they.
I'm not sure but I'd think that you could modify and alcohol stove for kerosene, but the tricky part may be finding the info you need (re jet sizes etc) to do the job safely and properly.
Another option might be to change parts between two stoves - kerosene stoves are cheap at recycle outfits too.
I've started calling up marine surplus shops and all they have are pulled origos, propane everything, and the occasional diesel giant. One went as far as trying to persuade me to go with the alcohol saying "why would you want to use kerosene anyway? No one does". Kerosene= cheaper fuel, less burned per unit of heat, I can see the flame (hate that about alcohol), and a much hotter flame. Being that I'm an avid cook, I can't see using that alcohol stove, there just isn't enough heat for some types of cooking. Those primus parts look promising, maybe I could just machine new brackets and replace the alcohol guts with the primus ones. Any thoughts?
Have a Force 10 Kero that had to be warmed up to run. That meant having two fuels on hand. The spirit/alcohol/kero thing was messy and a PIA. I found a butane single on sale and have used it for 5 years. The fuel has become very expensive due to hazmat regs, but it is reliable and very hot.
Now why would I want to use perfectly good moonshine to cook with instead of drinking it?
pigslo
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
SailNet Community
1.7M posts
173.8K members
Since 1990
A forum community dedicated to Sailing, boating, cruising, racing & chartering. Come join the discussion about sailing, destinations, maintenance, repairs, navigation, electronics, classifieds and more