
10-06-2008
|
|
Junior Member
|
|
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 4
Rep Power: 0
|
|
|
Why Internal Halliards?
You haven't mentioned why you want to install internal halliards. Personally, I wouldn't do it. I've had a number of keelers - from 9 to 15 metres - only one of which had internal halliards. That one [13m cutter] needed more vigilance over and maintenance of the rig than the others. Once a spinnaker halliard got 'sun poisoning' in just over a year, and snapped at the mast-head the next time it was used - reeving a new one was a real mission. ( Argument for carrying a trained rat in the crew?)
The running rigging on the gaff schooner I owned [or did it own me?] for a decade looked fierce, but it was all out where I could see it, maintain it, and get to it if anything did go wrong.
One of the Massed Bands of My Brothers-In-Law runs a Bavaria38 with the halliards run to the cockpit. It needs a lot of work to keep the cockpit from becoming a spaghetti factory under normal circumstances, and if a sail needs raising or lowering at night in a hurry - instant rat's nest!
Summing up, I'd put it thus; - The reduction in windage is more visual than real. Unless you're a hot racer or have a free-standing, full or semi-rotating airfoil mast, the gains are hardly worth it.
- Particularly if the lower sheaves are in the mast rather than on the step, compression strain on the mast is increased.
- Unnecessary complexity is added. The fewer twists and turns the line has to make going from sail to winch [or cleat], the lower the chances of something going wrong. Remember the KISS principle.
- The convenience and [theoretical] safety of working in the cocpit don't really outweigh the possible risk of going forward to the mast. Wear your harness, fit bum-bars if the boat's big enough.
- If you're worried about an external halliard getting loose and going to the masthead, consider an internal one going up to the masthead, through the sheave hole, and down into the mast. Happened to a friend of mine.
- Leave sailing under shelter to the junk-rig and wing-sail boys.
|