Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Annapolis, Md
Thanked 176 Times in 143 Posts
Rep Power: 10
Jeff_H & others?
First of all, most assymetrial performance results from an assymetrical installation of the knotmeter and/or wind instruments). Differences of as much as .3-.5 knots can occur simply from the placement of the knot meter and from different heel angles.
Really badly done keel and rudder fairing can in fact result in some assymetrical performance on the upwind tack but as Gordon notes, it would not be very big and it would not show up once the boat was off of the wind. To check your keel fairing symmetry you can wrap a horizontal section of your keel in Seran wrap (taping the seran wrap to the keel) and then make a rough corrigated carboard or thin plywood template pattern of your keel on one side marking the height of that pattern on both sides of the keel. This is a job best done by two or three people. Using an inexpensive bondo type automotive body filler, goop up the seran wrap in the horizonatal area where you plan to take your measurement and goop up the edge of the pattern as well. Then place the rough template against the hull, and while holdng the template in place so that it is close to horizontal, squigee the body filler so that the filler fills the void between the rough template and the seran wrap on the keel and is roughly the tickness of the template. Body putty cures pretty quickly so that you might only hold the template in place for 5 or so minutes since much of the cure time is used up applying the bondo to the template and seranwrap. When the bondo has started to gel, carefully untape the seran wrap and carefully remove the template and seran wrap from the keel. You will have a rough pattern of your keel on one side that you can compare with the other side. It will not be perfect but it will give you a sense of the fairness, and shape of that side. If you place the template against your hull on the other side it will give you a pretty reasonable idea of how similar the sections are from side to side. One word of caution about this, because of the keel taper, the top of the template from the side that was measured will be larger than the bottom. To check the profile the bottom of the template should be placed on your horizonatal marks and then sighted from below. Differences as large as a 1/4" are not all that uncommon, expecially on production boats with encapsulated keels.
But of course there are a lot of things that can cause assymetry in speed readings. Some are real differences in speed or pointing angles, and some are not. As Gordon notes, boats are not perfectly symetrical. Some items that can affect symmetrical performance would include:
-A mast or keel that is not vertical,
-Tanks (or gear storage) that are on one side of the boat or the other (When that tank is full that side of the boat would have more stability),
-Jib lead tracks, shrouds, spreader length and angle, and even maststeps or partners that are not symetrical in the boat.
-Differences in shroud tension or even the amount of use a shroud has been subjected to. (with use shrouds stretchiness can change and it not all that attypical for a boat (especially an offshore cruiser)to spent more of its life on one track. For example living here on the western shore of the Chesapeake it is more common for me to close reach on starboard to the Eastern Shore for the weekend and deep reach on port coming home),
-Right handed and left handed skippers (on many boats you end up steering each tack with a different hand, for most of us, this is no big deal as we quickly get used to doing that without thinking. But for some people this is much harder to do, so they always steer with the same hand (which means reaching across your body differently), or steer more poorly on one tack, as was the case of a skipper I raced with who would jerk the boat around more on starboard tack)
-On any given day, assymetry between tacks can result from the affects of waves and current. (Yesterday, I sailed a very interesting and tricky race in a pretty steep chop that was not square to the wind. The otherwise favored tack was squarer into the chop which meant a much harder slog against the waves. The speed difference between one tack and the other were nearly 3/4 of a knot.Interestingly, it was on the slower speed legs where we made our biggest gains against the fleet by playing the traveler (rather than steering as much)with almost every wave, finishing over 4 minutes ahead of the second boat finishing in our class (who owed us time) on a 12.5 mile couse. This was an extremely challenging race from a decision making point of view. Inshore there was a little less adverse current running but bigger waves. We chose to stay in the current rather than to deal with the waves and that seemed to pay off. As mainsail trimmer and helping with tactics I felt like I earned my keep yesterday.)
Is that what you had in mind when you asked the question?