The Nauticat 33 -- opinions please

[SPC]

Before I spend about a year's salary on one of these boats, I would appreciate some critical opinions.

True Blue was a great representative, but I would like more critical appraisals -- especially about the teak decks -- True Blue also sold his Nauticat.

My needs: I will sleep aboard 3 or 4 nights most weeks. I want to be comfortable when I do. I will usually manage the boat on my own. I like sailing but am not a zealot (no offense intended) and don't care about racing. I value wood craftsmanship very highly and I like some elbow room. My wife and I will spend about 10 weekends together on the boat and 3 to 4 guests will join us for 2 or 3 weekends.

I plan to day sail and fish in SF Bay on a regular basis and once every year or two, to make trips to Seattle, Santa Barbara, Bodega Bay, and Monterey. Beyond that, who knows?

On one hand, I have made a reasonable bid on a Passport 42 pilot house and a Cape Dory Motorsailer (MS3000). On the other hand, I like a Tayana 42 and a Passport 40 -- mainly for the craftsmanship below deck. On a third hand, I like a Grand Banks 32 for the ease of regular use and enjoyment.

I can spend from $60K to $120K as long as the purchase is a "bargain."

Your opinions are appreciated.

[christyleigh]

Originally Posted by SPC

True Blue was a great representative, but I would like more critical appraisals -- especially about the teak decks


>>>>>>>>>>>>> That's why I bought the only Nauticat I've ever seen or heard of without teak decks.


-- True Blue also sold his Nauticat.


>>>>>>>>>>>> He sold his Sailboat because his wife couldn't stand Sailing/Heeling any longer.


My needs: I will sleep aboard 3 or 4 nights most weeks. I want to be comfortable when I do. I will usually manage the boat on my own. I like sailing but am not a zealot (no offense intended) and don't care about racing. I value wood craftsmanship very highly and I like some elbow room. My wife and I will spend about 10 weekends together on the boat and 3 to 4 guests will join us for 2 or 3 weekends.


>>>>>>>>>>>>> You will be very crowded on those weekends.


I plan to day sail and fish in SF Bay on a regular basis and once every year or two, to make trips to Seattle, Santa Barbara, Bodega Bay, and Monterey. Beyond that, who knows?
On one hand, I have made a reasonable bid on a Passport 42 pilot house and a Cape Dory Motorsailer (MS3000). On the other hand, I like a Tayana 42 and a Passport 40 -- mainly for the craftsmanship below deck.


>>>>>>>>>>>>>> This size makes more sense for your stated use.


I can spend from $60K to $120K as long as the purchase is a "bargain."


>>>>>>>>>>> Nauticats are Never a Bargain. They are priced way into the obscenity range. You are looking at 20 year old Nauticat in that price range. I still owe the middle of your range to the bank for my 1999 purchased 5 years ago.

>>>>>>>>>> If you are really smitten by the Nauticats as I am I'd say look for a 20 year old 39 or 40 for your needs.

[sailingdog]

As Stan said... I doubt a 33' Nauticat is going to be well suited for your needs. You're looking at three 40-42' boats... and a 33' boat??? That doesn't even count the Grand Banks...

Given your budget, I think you're going to have some trouble finding any boat in the 38-42' range that is in decent shape, unless you're at the high end of your budget.