
12-27-2010
|
 |
baDumbumbum
|
|
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Windy Wyoming
Posts: 735
Rep Power: 5
|
|
|
Worth noting the Wiki article was written by an advocate; like everything in sailing, wishbone booms have advantages and disadvantages. Certainly they can be fast on small craft -- windsurfers have mucho speed -- and used with a flexy aluminum or carbon stick, they can supply radical prebend useful on small, fast craft. Bet they'd be killer on DN iceboats or Lasers! They are self-vanging and, with lazy jacks rigged off the boom, act like a stack-pack when you reef or drop your sail.
Downsides: you are limited to boom-end sheeting. Where is your vanging ability when boomed far out? Your ability to control twist? Not totally lost, but your snotter isn't going to work as well as a true vang, and you can't apply it w/out outhauling the clew, taking the draft out of your sail. Most performance sailing involves decoupling sail trim features like mast bend, outhaul, and vang; the wishbone doesn't permit that. Apply one, you apply all. Reefing is harder than pulling a sail down to a horizontal boom, the boom's weight is higher off the deck, and you need either a low tack or a high clew to get the most out of the configuration. You cant ease the boom as far on a stayed mast. And so on.
They are clever and a good solution for small boats, but they are not the preferred solution on all craft. If they were, the Volvo 70s would use them, you can be sure.
__________________
Buccaneer18, Grainnia
SJ21, Diarmuid
|