Fin vs bulb vs wing keels - Page 2 - SailNet Community

   Search Sailnet:

 forums  store  


Quick Menu
Forums           
Articles          
Galleries        
Boat Reviews  
Classifieds     
Search SailNet 
Boat Search (new)

Shop the
SailNet Store
Anchor Locker
Boatbuilding & Repair
Charts
Clothing
Electrical
Electronics
Engine
Hatches and Portlights
Interior And Galley
Maintenance
Marine Electronics
Navigation
Other Items
Plumbing and Pumps
Rigging
Safety
Sailing Hardware
Trailer & Watersports
Clearance Items

Advertise Here






Go Back   SailNet Community > General Interest > General Discussion (sailing related)
 Not a Member? 


Like Tree13Likes
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
  #11  
Old 10-12-2012
grumpy old man
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 3,544
Thanks: 1
Thanked 72 Times in 68 Posts
Rep Power: 4
bobperry will become famous soon enough
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

We may be on thin ice here lumping all wing keels into one category. There is no question that when you are up gainst a hard draft restrcition a wing can work quite well.
The Aussie winged keel worked well in conjunction with the upside down profile of that keel and the extra long tip chord with it's vortex problems.

When I designed the Islander 34 we did a 5.5' draft wing keel and a 7' draft straight fin. Islander built one of each as hulls 1 and 2. They were launched the same day with sails from the same sailmaker. I flew down with one of my helpers, a very good sailor, and for two days we raced these two boats against each other. The difference in speed was minimal if present at all. And, I was a skeptic to begin with. But after trading boats and sailing them upwind and down. I came away a believer. The wing keel boat was a bit slower off the wind, not much. Up wind the two boats were pretty much identical in VMG. This is not theory. This is first hand sailing experience with two identical boats.

But wings to be effective have to have aspect ratio just like fins. Short, thick stubby wings, like we have seen on many production models, are not efficient. They may do a nice job at lowering the VCG but they can be a lot of drag and be wonderful Bruce type anchors if you get stuck in the mud.

All I'm saying is to treat wings on keels on an individual basis.
__________________
Please visit my blog. It's fun to read.


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Bob's Blog ....


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.

Last edited by bobperry; 10-12-2012 at 05:40 PM.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
  #12  
Old 10-12-2012
jimrafford's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: ct
Posts: 545
Thanks: 0
Thanked 8 Times in 8 Posts
Rep Power: 4
jimrafford is on a distinguished road
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

Every foil section is different. Some of the production wings just look wrong.
CS called the wing on my boat a hydrofoil. It is larger than any other wing I have ever seen. W/o measuring it's about 6' wide and 5' deep.
I have yet to meet another cruising boat that can out point w/ me and there has yet to be another similar boat I can't catch off the wind.
But that's my foil section. I think Tony Castro did some research.
Jim
__________________
S/V Deja Vu
CS 40

Last edited by jimrafford; 10-12-2012 at 07:01 PM.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
  #13  
Old 10-13-2012
CBinRI's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 912
Thanks: 1
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Rep Power: 11
CBinRI is on a distinguished road
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

As to shoal keels, fin is best for performance, and the deeper the better. You will point higher and track better. And if you race, whatever handicap you are given for another form of draft will not be enough. Don't have any experience with bulbs.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
  #14  
Old 10-13-2012
RobGallagher's Avatar
HANUMAN
 
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Noank, Connecticut, USA
Posts: 1,314
Thanks: 7
Thanked 12 Times in 11 Posts
Rep Power: 13
RobGallagher is on a distinguished road
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

After I decided what boat I way buying, I chose a wing keel over the deeper fin keel model because of draft restrictions.

Does that make me a draft dodger?
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
  #15  
Old 10-13-2012
Faster's Avatar
Just another Moderator
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: New Westminster, BC
Posts: 14,604
Thanks: 67
Thanked 178 Times in 174 Posts
Rep Power: 10
Faster has a spectacular aura about Faster has a spectacular aura about Faster has a spectacular aura about
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

Quote:
Originally Posted by RobGallagher View Post

Does that make me a draft dodger?
... or it just means you're a bit shallow.....
RobGallagher and chef2sail like this.
__________________
Ron

1984 Fast/Nicholson 345 "FastForward"

".. there is much you could do at sea with common sense.. and very little you could do without it.."
Capt G E Ericson (from "The Cruel Sea" by Nicholas Monsarrat)
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
  #16  
Old 10-20-2012
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: Michigan
Posts: 180
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Rep Power: 3
BryceGTX is on a distinguished road
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

I view the differences between these keel designs from a number of angles:

First is the performance issue to to change in resistance. Rather than calculate actual resistance, I can look at wetted surface. It is interesting to compare the wetted surface between the wing keel version of my boat (Catalina 400) to the fin keel version.

When I crunch the numbers, I find that the wetted surface of the wing keel version is less than 4% higher than the fin keel. Granted, the resistance is probably less; however this shows how little effect the wing keel has on the overall resistance.

A rough calculation of the difference between a bulb at the same draft, with the same righting moment, I would find the difference between the bulb and the wing to be a similar 4%.

One has to wonder if the 4% difference is significant. It might be interesting to look at some of the advantages of the wing keel versus the others. A quick look at Wikipedia gives a bit of insite:


Last edited by BryceGTX; 10-20-2012 at 07:17 PM.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
  #17  
Old 10-20-2012
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: Michigan
Posts: 180
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Rep Power: 3
BryceGTX is on a distinguished road
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

Now comes the interesting possibilities of a wing keel.

One aspect I find intriguing is the possibility that a wing keel is capable of increasing its leway resistance as the boat heels because its effective vertical surface area increases as it heels (as long as the wing is large enough). Neither the bulb nor the fin keel provide this benefit. Rather both the fin and bulb keels reduce their vertical surface as the boat heels. This increase in leway resistance can be quite dramatic for a wing keel designed to optimize this effect. The wing must be a resonable size. Also, as stated, the dynamic effects of water at the root of the keel.

The next aspect I find intriguing is that the wing keel is the only keel of the three that actually creates damping in the vertical direction. Furthermore, it can damp in the rising motion of the boat! This damping could be advantageous in reducing the dynamic motions of sailboats. Obviously, the hull creates damping as the hull falls, but the wing (unlike the hull) additionally provides damping as the hull rises.

The third aspect of the keels is damping to rolling. The wing keel also provides damping benefit to rolling due to its overall surface area and flow resistance at the root. The bulb keel provides no damping benefit from the bulb design, only due to the vertical area. The fin keel provides more damping benefit to rolling than the wing keel only if it is deeper.

I have a wing keel as I want shallow water capability. In the numerous times I have grounded, I have not ever needed to be pulled off, nor have I required a kedge. One interesting advantage, is that my wing keel increases draft as the boat heels (to a point). The result is that I suspect I am less likely to sail onto a shallow without my keel hitting. And when it hits, the large frontal area does not allow the wing to travel much into the shallow. These two effects, I suspect may make it less likely to get heavily grounded.

However, I appeciate the viewpoint of the wing acting as a disadvantage on a heavy grounding.

Last edited by BryceGTX; 10-20-2012 at 07:57 PM.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
  #18  
Old 10-20-2012
grumpy old man
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 3,544
Thanks: 1
Thanked 72 Times in 68 Posts
Rep Power: 4
bobperry will become famous soon enough
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

GTX:
Amazing, How scientific.
I do it the Neantherthal way:
I build two identical boats.
I give one a deep draft fin
I give one a shoal draft wing keel.
It's kind of hands on.
I give them identical suits of sails.
I give each boat a very competant crew.
I sail the two boats against each other for a couple of days.
I report on my findings.

Somewhere along the way I forgot to "crunch the numbers".
I was too busy sailing the boats.

But I am lucky. I have the benefit of testing these things in the real word.
__________________
Please visit my blog. It's fun to read.


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Bob's Blog ....


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
  #19  
Old 10-21-2012
grumpy old man
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 3,544
Thanks: 1
Thanked 72 Times in 68 Posts
Rep Power: 4
bobperry will become famous soon enough
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

My last post was made after a long and hard and succesful day of racing in lots of wind. I was tired and re-reading my post it now seems a bit snotty. My excuse is, I was feeling snotty. I'll work on being nicer next time.
__________________
Please visit my blog. It's fun to read.


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Bob's Blog ....


To view links or images in signatures your post count must be 10 or greater. You currently have 0 posts.
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
  #20  
Old 10-21-2012
RandyonR3's Avatar
Cruising
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: crusing
Posts: 146
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
Rep Power: 9
RandyonR3 is on a distinguished road
Re: Fin vs bulb vs wing keels

Quote:
Originally Posted by bobperry View Post
My excuse is, I was feeling snotty.
Its a result of putting up with Idots all your life Bob.. In my 60s, I've delt with
many of the same.. and just the other day, I had someone at the Yacht Club Bar compairing his Full keel, Hans from the 70s to my First 42, in "race" criteria..
After about 10 minutes of his ramble, Instead of a rebutle, I just told him he was full of crap and I got up and left..
At one time, it was the chalange of the argument, Now days, dont have time for it..

sorry for the drift, now back to the origional channel..............
__________________
Visit Our Site at SailingOnR3.com
Reply With Quote Share with Facebook
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools

 
Posting Rules
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may post attachments
You may edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Wing, fin, or bulb...what are the trade offs? langousta Gear & Maintenance 17 09-17-2008 04:54 PM
Iron Keels Versus Lead Keels twofish81 Gear & Maintenance 14 12-02-2007 01:58 PM
Iron Keels Versus Lead Keels twofish81 Sailboat Design and Construction 4 11-30-2007 10:55 AM
Fixed Keels vs. Swing Keels Dan Dickison Buying a Boat Articles 0 05-21-2001 08:00 PM
wing keels mcchoi Cruising & Liveaboard Forum 3 09-29-2000 06:20 PM


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:36 AM.

Add to My Yahoo!         
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
SEO by vBSEO 3.6.1
(c) Marine.com LLC 2000-2012

The SailNet.com store is owned and operated by a company independent of the SailNet.com forum. You are now leaving the SailNet forum. Click OK to continue or Cancel to return to the SailNet forum.