|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|02-05-2009 08:29 PM|
I'll second ZZ's comments. I have a relatively lightweight Gill jacket and pants that I got at the boat show for cheap. They were "last year's" colors, but I don't care. They keep me dry without too much additional warmth in the summer.
In the winter, I add a Musto windstopper jacket. Most of the time, I wear it with a sweatshirt underneath and skip the outer jacket since I'm not usually out if it's cold and raining. I have ocassionally worn the sweatshirt and the windstopper and the outer jacket, but then I worry what I'd do if I went overboard. Frankly, if it's that cold and wet, I'll stay home.
|02-05-2009 07:13 PM|
|tonybinTX||Don't forget your feet! For me - cold/wet feet shut me down quicker than anything else. I suggest over the calf leather boots with gore tex liners built in. You can also get gore tex socks.|
|02-05-2009 04:51 PM|
HL offshore hi-fit pants and jacket. Pick a set up at a boat shoe and save 300+ bucks.
Foulies don't need to be really warm, they're there to keep your other warm layers dry. Keep your water proof layer light and breathable.
ps - top should be bright, bottoms I chose to go dark. Pants get dirty rather quickly, and if your in the water, no one sees your legs anyway.
|02-05-2009 03:22 PM|
I picked up this set a few seasons back and have really enjoyed it:
Against The Elements IM-4
May not be warm enough for the North but it has always kept me dry.
Hope it helps...
|01-31-2009 07:38 AM|
|sailingdog||The collar and hood are really key to keeping warm and dry. Also, double cuffs on the sleeves are important. Nothing sucks worse than reaching up to adjust something and have water run down your arm and soak you. Good foul weather gear will have an inner cuff that has a rubber, pvc, or neoprene seal that prevents that from happening.|
|01-30-2009 09:22 PM|
Even some of the companies that carry other fabrics will admit nothing compares to GoreTex, but after 6-8 years of heavy use even the best GoreTex seems to go porous and start leakin gin hevy weather. I've been through this 3-4 times over the last 20 years, the Extreme Wet Weather warranty and all are nice--but sooner or later the stuff sadly fails.
GREAT for the first five years, though.
In humid hot summer months, GoreTex is the only way to survive. In more reasonable weather, I caught some Henry Lloyd gear on sale at the end of season and swear by it. You can pick up raingear from camping and hunting suppliers for a fraction of the "marine" price, but it is harder to find it in "safety" colors that are easy to spot in you go overboard.
Whatever you wind up going for--fit is paramount. Especially, a good collar and hood to keep rain out, and wrist seals of some type. With pants, you are best off with bibs of some type, so that breaking water can't sneak up under your jacket and over low pants.
REI, Campmore, Sierra Trading, all are good camping sources.
|01-30-2009 08:54 PM|
Originally Posted by genieskip View Post
The wet you experienced is most likely your own body vapor being trapped by significantly reduced breathability most likely due to "wet out" of the outer fabric.
The pores in the PTFE membrane Gore-tex is made of are physically too small for a water molecule to pass through. If you want to prove this theory simply place a Gore-Tex garment over a dry cereal bowl and depress the garment to make a catch basin. Then pour some water onto the jacket. It will not leak through.
I remember when gore-Tex first came out they had these store displays which were a tall cylinder with a Goretex membrane in the middle. The top of the cylinder was filled with water and the bottom was air with a small pump. You could pump air into the cylinder and watch the bubbles rise up through the water but the membrane never let water in.
Gore-tex is indeed water proof but you sweat and produce much more vapor than you realize and you get wet from the inside not the out.. Also when the fabric wets out and comes in contact with your skin it can actually cause condensation on top of sweat..
Hope that makes sense..
Oh and you can use NikWax TX Direct to re-apply the DWR to any Gore-tex garment if it's wetting out..
|01-30-2009 08:12 PM|
There are plus's and minus's to both IMHO. IE the rubber coated you will NOT get wet from the outside. BUT< if you dress too warmly, you will sweat, and get wet from the inside!
The breathables in lighter rain or just say sunny but waves and water splashing on you, windy etc, at least the sweat vapor will evaporate to the outside of the gear for the most part. Not always, but generally speaking. Then usually it will repel water from the outside in, BUT if you sit in a puddle, or it is raining really hard, lots of water from waves spray etc getting on you, the material will leak outside to inside, or if the seams are not properlly sealed etc.
It is one of those you need to figure out how bad it is going to be, what conditions etc. I find at work, I can usually dress for the temp, and the little dampness I get from sweat is easier to deal with than rain soaking into me. Plus when you work in dirt like I do, dirt etc can get into the breathable fabric and cause it not to work, so it leaks, does not breath etc. For active sports I usually do not have issues with breathables, unless skiing I sit on a chairlift with slushy snow on the seat, the boat has standing water on the seats etc, then my butt will get wet really quick, hence why in these conditions, I like rubber bottoms, and a brethable top. Other time with light wetness, not sitting in water etc, the breathable bottoms work fine. This is where I have more issues than not
|01-30-2009 08:08 PM|
|genieskip||Breathable stuff will leak sooner or later. Rubberized stuff will get you wet with perspiration from the inside. Nothing's perfect - you choose your poison. The wettest I've ever been offshore has been with GoreTex FWG that was more like a sieve than any real protection - admittedly a long time ago but I've been skittish about the material ever since. If you really want to stay dry wear something waterproof (rubberized) and some fleece to absorb moisture. On my boat I carry an expensive breathable FWG for when it's mildly wet and some Nova Scotia fisherman's rubber gear for when it's really wet.|
|01-30-2009 07:56 PM|
|wchevron||a 30 yr. lobsterman i know uses grundens exclusively. it gets hot in the summer though. not very breathable.|
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|