|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|11-28-2010 06:15 PM|
|coreywoodworking||I got sucked in, too. New to Sailnet, I somehow think things are current, but will check the post dates from now on. Thank you all.|
|11-28-2010 06:05 PM|
|coreywoodworking||I'm elsewhere on Sailnet, asking "Am I nuts to ditch the diesel for an outboard?" and I'm following the collective advice to get to know the diesel. Still, I know the C26 (and envy your shallow draft K/CB) and you'd have to cut up a lot to fit a diesel. I once owned a Bristol 26 and 27, both with outboards and did a survey on the Bristol page. Of 35 replies, the conclusion was 6-8 HP, four-stroke, high-thrust prop (very important) and 25" shaft (also very important to keep prop low in a seaway.) Use the Garelick motor mount that hikes the engines 15" up and I think you'll be great. I'm headed for the Bahamas myself in 2012. Look for Nanagram, a Caliber 28|
|11-19-2010 07:08 AM|
Originally Posted by paulk View Post
diesels have MORE torque than gas.. torque is rotational force, not HP... for the same hp diesels have WAY more torque.
what has happened with these swap outs is that the rpm changes...
if you switch from an atomic 4 to a diesel, you will have to at the minimum have the prop re pitched.. maybe even an new different diameter prop...
a diesel inboard is the most reliable (other than electric) propulsion you can have. by their design they last longer.. they use a light oil for combustion. this in and of itself will help lubricate moving parts.
but i do agree that if your boat did not originally have an inboard... stick with the outboard.
|09-17-2009 03:29 PM|
outboards cavitate (lift out of the water in rough water when you need them most) no matter how well they are mounted. on the plus side they run great and for hours on end, no where near the problems as 2strokes.
I love my Diesel inboard and don't think I'd ever want a boat without one. on a 26ft CB boat though, The question of where the inboard would go in relation to the cb trunk and the cb when it's up, engine access, engine cradle, batteries, then the controls, the shaft log, shaft, cutless bearing and strut, water lift muffler, raw water intake with strainer, diesel tank, tank plumbing, filter, pump, bilge access just to mention a few things.
Your taking a 26ft cb boat on the ocean? Hope you have the experiance for such a trip!
|09-17-2009 01:39 PM|
Go Outboard do NOT redesign...
I have a 25' Morgan with a Yanmar and a 27' catalina with a Nissan 4 stroke, I have to pull the morgan every few months and scrape the prop with teh Morgan, when it's clean it's great but I would not redesign my Catalina to utilize the Yanmar, I like being able to pull the engine off in 60 seconds if I need service, for the money you put into redesign to support the Yanmar you can have a spare outboard...
|11-19-2008 05:06 AM|
If the boat can take the inboard diesel without weeks and weeks of modification, then it would be diesel for me.
It will outlast any outboard, 2 or 3 times over, and storing gasoline aboard for any reasonable range will be difficult.
The diesel will use less fuel, has no spark ignition to get damp, and is a better set-up for heavier weather.
For me, it would be diesel.
|11-18-2008 08:39 PM|
|KODAD||wait for it................................................ .|
|11-18-2008 08:38 PM|
Be careful withe the search function! You just responded to a thread that is now six years old.... Good post but I doubt the OP is still listening ...
|11-18-2008 08:27 PM|
Diesel Inboard vs Petrol Outboard
Originally Posted by bugged View Post
Jims next boat was a Hurley 27 (AKA Dockrell 27). Less grand than the Westerly but IMHO its Betamarine BZ13 (a twin) was impeccable, SMOOTH RUNNING, of course the previous owner paid a lot of money for that engine. I sailed (motored actually) round The Lizard on that boat doing Plymouth, Falmouth, Penzance. At times did hear the Beta race as the prop lost its grip whilst punching against wind and tide so I doubt whether an outboard could have done it. Even with diesel economy several imperial gallons were consumed and an outboard would have used double the amount. Two mishaps occurred on that trip. Firstly the pitching of the boat frayed through the cord supporting the radar reflector. It fell from the crosstrees and was blown backwards into the cockpit where it felled the skipper. The next mishap was a broken battery terminal. Cheap zinc alloy plated to look like brass! Luckily we had Mole grips (vise grip pliers) on board, but those fake brass battery terminals ought to be banned as they are a safety hazard.
Good Luck! but as always its horses for courses.
|03-24-2002 01:23 PM|
Diesel vs 4 stroke outboard???
I am not exactly sure of your situation but if you are considering re-powering with an outboard and... would like to have a diesel... there are diesel outboards. Yanmar makes 27 and 36hp ob''s, not sure if there are other models. Might be a possible solution for you. Something worth checking into. Sorry I cannot be more specific.
Hope this helps.
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|