|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|12-13-2011 01:18 PM|
Originally Posted by InkyMatt View Post
You can also use the experience of the instructor to avoid some emergencies.
In many ways dinghies will help to improve your sailing skills, they will not be of much assistance in developing cruising skills and knowledge.
|12-13-2011 01:07 PM|
I think it's important to take a certified course, as well as get a lot of experience.
For myself, i know i'm new. I started sailing 8 months ago. I took my Basic Keelboating Standard, read 'The Sailing Bible', 'Sailing For Dummies', and 'The Complete Sailor'. After that, I logged over 150 hours this summer cruising and racing my club's fleet of J24s. After one season, i'm quite capable of safely single-handing a small keelboat. I also know that I'm not familiar enough for the 30'-plus yachts yet. That's what I'm expecting my Intermediate Standard to help with.
The summer's cruising/racing experience taught me much more than the course did, but the course went through the safety aspects that are necessary and often overlooked if you just buy a boat and cast off. Similar to taking Drivers Education before getting your driver's license, you'll be fine 99% of the time but might need that special training for the dangerous 1%. To me, the danger of not knowing what to do in an emergency justifies taking formal training.
|12-13-2011 10:18 AM|
|SeaMck333||I agree with Sailingfool and you guys. I took the class for keelboating, but supplementing with reading book after book and also crewing a bit. I feel comfortable on a boat, and ready for a first season exploring locally sailing on my boat and on others. The catch is that the classes are just a great way to get some hands on experience thats all about your skill level. I dont recommend assuming competence based on certificates, that comes only with experience. I do recommend classes, because it will be a great way to get familiar and learn the safe way to do things (often not taught by friends or other sailors), and because it's a fun albeit small part of learning to sail...|
|12-13-2011 09:13 AM|
|Mirari||I think rather than spending hundreds of dollars on a sailing course you might want to put the money into a small sailing dink and spend a season all by yourself sailing it and observing how the boat responds. You can supplement this by reading a few books but nothing beats one on one with just you and the wind. From there you can move up to larger and larger vessels. When you can dock a full keel boat like an Ensign under just sail alone you can assume you are now compentent enough to take on a larger vessel. It seems too many folks want to jump into a 35 or larger vessel and go cruising by paying for a course and getting a certificate rather than spending time on the water all by yourself.|
|12-13-2011 09:00 AM|
|davidpm||Even after they get their 1 week cert most people can tell that they are not really sailors yet. Trust your own gut not someone you paid a few hundred to for a piece of paper for your own safety.|
|12-13-2011 08:15 AM|
I personally do not think you can become a competent sailor in a week of courses. Competency requires some level of hands-on experience from which you develop the necessary judgement and responses. I'd suggest you look around for a local club, some one must be frostbiting int he area, and see if you can spend get some weekends in as crew and then skippers in small boats. The take your classes.
If you do the class (and get the certifications as I suspect you would), be sure next Spring to get yourselves into a club boat somewhere and spend a few weeks with your hands on a tiller...before you head out of a harbor as the skipper of a cruising boat....
|12-13-2011 08:02 AM|
|SeaMck333||Check out www.sailingwithcaptainfrank.com. I took my basic keelboat with him here in NC, but he gos anywhere to teach I think. I recommend him not only on merit of professionalism but also because he's just a good guy you wouldn't mind spending your vacation with. We keep in contact with him and he helped us buy our first boat. Can't say enough good things!|
|12-13-2011 07:30 AM|
My apologies for the confusion! The night passage was unrelated to the school.
Poor sentence structure...
It was my first night passage after becoming a sailor so to speak. I was on a boat owned by a captain who did exactly as you said Jackdale. He was just surprised that the school never even showed us a chart, among other things.
Inky: it's not the same school you went to. And it was the basic keelboat cruising course.
Our on water instructor was actually pretty good. The school, not so much. It could have been worse though. The other half of the class got a different instructor, one day he was teaching Mediterranean mooring for some reason. We could hear him talking about how to dock a 50 foot sailboat in Greece or something .... and our instructor mumbled something to the effect of "Yah like that's exactly what your students need to learn".
|12-12-2011 11:20 PM|
Ninefingers, the more I think, i'm wondering if i'm misunderstanding your post.
There's a 20-water-hour course for around $600, but it's the Basic Standard. And that certainly wouldn't have an overnight...
It also might be a different school than mine, I know they don't have a Catalina at the moment.
|12-12-2011 11:14 PM|
Interesting. My course is also through a Toronto school starting with an 'H'. And as far as I know, the only one starting with an 'H'...
I asked a few sailing friends for recommendations, and they uninimously named this school. I joined in May for my Basic Standard, got a membership with them, and sailed 3-4 nights per week throughout the summer. I learned a lot, and made a lot of new friends.
If we're talking about the same school, i'm surprised at the negative view. Although they DO now make the first half of Coastal Navigation (chartplotting fundamentals) a prerequisite for the intermediate. The instructor told me that he wanted to make the whole thing a prerequisite, but the CYA refused. So far, i've taken my Basic, VHF Radio, and Coastal Navigation courses through them. And honestly, i would be hard-pressed to come up with any negative criticism...
How long ago did you take your Intermediate? I'm also curious because overnight passages aren't part of this school's Intermediate - it's part of the Advanced Standard...
My BVI Intermediate course is also through this same school, there are a bunch of us flying down and chartering a couple of yachts with our Toronto instructors.
Jackdale's list looks to be a part of what we'll be learning (although 1/2 of it has already been taught in the other courses).
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|