|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|02-05-2007 02:22 PM|
Originally Posted by sailingdog
I was just responding to a more general Hunter side of the question. I myself believe that a more comprehensive method be used to ground the boat than just the compression post to keel cable.
|02-05-2007 01:23 PM|
There is no reason you can't use an unencapsulated metal keel for a ground in a lightning protection system. If the keel is encapsulated, then you will have a problem if you do so...but with an unencapsulated keel, it should be fine.
I'd second reading the website that CruisingDad pointed out... it is very comprehensive and detailed.
If the compression post was stainless steel, then your grounding system was probably inadequate as a lightning protection system. Stainless steel has a fairly high electrical resistance, which is also why you shouldn't use stainless steel washers in your electrical setup.
|02-05-2007 12:56 PM|
As usual there are a number of prior threads on this subject. Here's one: http://www.sailnet.com/forums/hersai...ight=lightning. My post in that thread has this link http://www.kastenmarine.com/Lightning.htm which is required reading on this subject.
As I recall all the material, you want to have your mast gounded, and that will provide primary protection to the people on the boat and to the intergrity of the hull, in the case of a lightning strike. If your boat doesn't have one, which I would find surprising even on a low budget production builder, then you should install such as described in SD's first post above.
I make a distinction between grounding the mast and a full protection system that bonds all metal parts to ground. The first is essential and should be universally provided, the second is less common and expensive, and in my personal opinion, the retrofit cost not worth the benefit.
|02-05-2007 12:55 PM|
Grounding your boat is more than just running a #4 to the keel. It is VERY involved and detailed and a half-ass job IS MORE dangerous than not doing it at all. You can ground to the keel, but the current "Theory (to point this back to our glbal warming thread)" is not using the keel as a ground point but a special gound strip (and for God's sake, not your bronze ground plate for your SSB).
Here is an OK write-up for grounding. I have a print off that is better, but will need to find it if you are interested. It is very nicely detailed. Both of these are proponents of grounding your boat, and as a note, the second is just a scientist and is not selling anything. However, even reading Nigel Calder's Bible, he is a huge advocate of grounding and seems to portray (as they all do) that grounding DECREASES your chances of getting hit. For me, I do not see how that is possible... but am grounding anyways.
This is a good way to get you started. It is a very detailed subect. I don't know where you are based out of, but I lived (and am about to live again) in SW Florida which is the lightning capial of this hemisphere... and ever day we weathered a strom and never got popped. Boats around us were not as lucky.
|02-05-2007 12:39 PM|
On my old 1982 Hunter 33 there was a a heavy ground wire attached to the compression Post to the keel bolts. The mast cradle was thru bolted to the the compression post. One of the features of the hunter line is that the keels are cast lead and not encapsulated so this might in fact work. Given the shortest distance theory I tend to agree with SD that providing a path may increase risk. Best bet is to be next to a 40' boat with a mast taller than yours.
|02-05-2007 12:31 PM|
Originally Posted by Cruisingdad
|02-05-2007 12:30 PM|
Originally Posted by Cruisingdad
|02-05-2007 12:26 PM|
|Cruisingdad||You don't have to get hit for the electronics to get toasted.|
|02-05-2007 12:18 PM|
Current theory is that boats that are grounded get hit more often than boats that are not grounded. However, it seems that boats that are grounded suffer less damage when hit than do boats that are ungrounded.
So, it really depends on what your risk tolerance is... are you willing to risk getting hit more often, which is still relatively rare, and suffer a less catastrophic strike, or willing to risk a more catastrophic strike with a lower chance of getting hit to begin with.
Generally, even on a well-grounded boat, the electronics are toast if you're hit.
|02-05-2007 12:13 PM|
I seriously, seriously doubt it. Very few production boats run LP... and you will find many customs that do not either. It may have been added later by a previous owner if it is there.
Are you considering grounding your boat?
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|