|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|07-24-2007 08:07 AM|
Yeah, I saw that history document. Pretty interesting. The Venture did seem to start the category. IMO Catalina upped the ante another foot and pretty much ruled it with the 22 (I think that it was the best selling of the similar boats). The variance in SJs muddies 1D racing a bit, but it does still have the advantages you mention.
|07-24-2007 12:56 AM|
Here is a link off a SJ28 page I found when looking for my current boat. Thought about the SJ28. That 14 page PDF is a history of the Clark Boat company that manufactured SJ's and C-larks among others.
It has a part where as Cobra Charlie mentions in your other thread, ie the Venture starting the trailer sailer era. It has a few other notes about SJ's as to why they might be a bit better than other brands and a bit quicker too. On the other hand, it mentions that there are about 6-10 SJ21's that were made a layer or two thicker than most! IE they went into the chater trade in Fl, and they were knowingly going to get beached, and removed via a long forklift, hence the thicker hulls, along with one heck of a lot slower than the normal thickness hulls........
You can race PHRF with ANY boat. There is some portions of racing that is nice to do 1D too. IE sharing sails, rigging and other parts, idea's etc if need be with in the club. With in this thought, you may also learn to sail a bit quicker if you have the same boat as others within the club, as there will be more how to make the boat quicker etc.
Also, I am recalling, while the Mk II version does race side by side with the original deck version, I seem to recall that the original cabin version is a bit quicker generally speaking. I did not sail both models, so will not speak from experience on this item. This may be spelled out in the article I linked too!
Good luck with choice, in realty, there is no WRONG choice. Other than my choice! oh yeah, I did not have a choice now did I!!!
|07-23-2007 12:23 PM|
Originally Posted by arbarnhart View Post
|07-23-2007 05:59 AM|
Originally Posted by blt2ski View Post
|07-23-2007 05:54 AM|
Originally Posted by bobmcgov View Post
|07-23-2007 12:02 AM|
|bobmcgov||The SJ21 is my dream boat. Went with a Bucc18 for now; a little bit easier to trailer and launch. Love the SJ's heavy swing keel & that it is both fast and forgiving. Bet it's easier to single-hand than our Bucc.|
|07-22-2007 10:47 PM|
|sailaway21||I'd be looking at the Santanas also.|
|07-22-2007 05:28 PM|
I used to sailin a local club on Lk Washington as a teen with a few SJ21's. Nice boat overall. As far as what is better.....that question is only one you can answer. And you have answered one, which is that there is a local club that races them. If youwant to race 1D, then get an SJ21. I built a small pram as a teen, wish I would have built an ElToro vs the GlenL 8 ball, as there was an eltoro group to race in. Not that I did not have fun with my pram, but, the racing woul dhave made it more FUN!
So your reason to go with an SJ21 vs a C21 or equal, has as much merit as any other thing some have said about other 20-22' Trailer sailers.
|07-22-2007 03:07 PM|
|arbarnhart||I may be narrowing back down to the SJ 21 though. I do want to participate in races and regattas locally and so far, it is the only trailerable crusing racer in my budget range I have found a local group for.|
|07-22-2007 10:51 AM|
Yeah, and guess what lighter means?
You guessed it! Quicker and more agile. One of the most endearing features of the Cal 21 is that she'll get right up and going quickly, even in very light air. She carries a lot of sail for the size boat, coupled with an 1100 lb displacement, and you get the picture.
Only deficiency, imho, head-room or lack thereof.
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|