|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|11-09-2007 10:53 PM|
Wow, almost four months this thread has been going
I'd like thank everybody for their comments.
I think, from what I've read here, I'm satisfied an Origo non-pressurized alcohol stove would be the way for us to go. It seems to me much simpler (I like simple) and somewhat safer.
It's not something we're likely to do right away, in any event. This upgrade will wait until we seriously start to plan our first cruise. That's probably a ways off.
|11-09-2007 09:26 PM|
I can't resist getting into this one! Our Origo has worked well for over 20 years. We replaced the canisters 2 years ago. As an example, I've cooked Chicken piccatta and pasta on it, bacon and eggs, pan fried fish and steaks with steak fries, broccoli and gravy, Chinese dishes and if you check out my photo gallery on this site you can see the cake http://www.sailnet.com/photogallery/.../ppuser/132057 and Italian bread http://www.sailnet.com/photogallery/.../ppuser/132057 we bake in our Coleman camper stove set on top of one burner. You can't bake bread without good temperature control and with the thermometer on the Coleman it is easy and precise. I've made time comparisons of using propane vs unpressurized alcohol and the difference is insignificant. I considered switching to propane which is great cooking fuel but given the safety factor we decided to stay with the Origo. We do have a propane Magma grill and a 6lb aluminum bottle mounted on the stern rail.
bsfree, just get an oven thermometer at the hardware store and you'll be able to get it precisely! Also our fuel consumption is the same as you state about a gallon a month using it every day.
|11-07-2007 11:13 AM|
I'm very happy with my Origo 6000, cooked a delicious roast chicken this past weekend, and while it is true that the temp control is not precise I have learned to use the oven more by "feel" than numbers. The top burners work just fine for me. I think it's an individual preference whether one goes with propane or alcohol, the reality is they both are capable of cooking a decent meal, safely, how decent will depend on the cook!
There has been a lot of debate over propane v alcohol, I myself asked for advice here before I went the alcohol way, mainly because of the simplicity. It is more expensive, cost me approx $14 a gallon which lasts around 4 weeks cooking every day.
All the best
|11-07-2007 10:29 AM|
|fordo||The Tartan 30 I bought had an Origo that the PO had put in to replace the pressurized alcohol stove. I was very pleasantly suprised by how good it is. Much faster than I expected. Retrofitting for propane can be a real pain and pressurized alcohol can be very annoying, especially as these stoves are now pretty old. If it is not easy to install the propane go with the Origo. I am told that West Marine handles these stoves on a special order basis. Good Luck! Ford|
|10-28-2007 10:59 AM|
Non-pressurized alcohol works fine for me
This last trip out, I cooked and baked using a pressure cooker and the non-pressuized Origo. It worked just fine.
The preference here seems similar to discussion of electric windlasses in a way. Is it important to you do things quickly (electric windlass, propane stove/oven) or would you rather not have to operate and maintain complicated systems (non-pressure alcohol, manual or no windlass)?
I have to keep it simple.
|10-28-2007 08:26 AM|
I'm glad you like the Aeropress. I've given a few away as gifts...they're great.
|10-28-2007 08:15 AM|
|Joesaila||We checked out a lot of the old post when our 30' Morgan OI came with a new Origo non pressurized Alc. and almost bought the arguments about the slow cooking Origo but one sailer said she had used one for about 10 years and loved it so we decided to give it a try. It works great, we love it too and while it lacks an oven it cooks and heats our food and coffee fine. We use denatured Alch. from most any hardware store and at the suggestion of one of the experts purchased an Aeropress coffee maker [you only heat the water to 165-175 degrees to make perfect coffee]. We have owned and used propane on other boats and yes its faster but the expense [and danger] does not make it worthwhile to us. Try it, then decide. You too may be pleasantly surprised.|
|07-26-2007 10:19 PM|
|Sailormann||I have a converter on my boat - not an inverter, hence I think that I have to use a 12V microwave... The batteries have 230 amp hours (when they were new - about 7 years old now). So when I looked at the RV microwaves I believe they were drawing close to 100 amps, which I figured would probably wipe the batteries out fast.|
|07-26-2007 03:09 PM|
Originally Posted by TrueBlue View Post
|07-26-2007 11:53 AM|
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|