SailNet Community - Reply to Topic
Seamanship & Navigation Forum devoted to seamanship and navigation topics, including paper and electronic charting tools.

Thread: A gripe - The most unseamanlike vessels on the planet? Reply to Thread
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the SailNet Community forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
Please note: After entering 3 characters a list of Usernames already in use will appear and the list will disappear once a valid Username is entered.

User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:


Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.

  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

Click here to view the posting rules you are bound to when clicking the
'Submit Reply' button below

  Topic Review (Newest First)
10-11-2007 11:11 PM
Lancer28 I've always been under the impression that a Boat goes ON a Ship... so for me, boat applies to anything dinghy or tender-esque...

I think we should really work on enforcement of current issues as a #1 thing to work on.
Next, how about requiring all boats to carry insurance (that could reduce my nerves about floating buttholes), in which the insurance companies require certain safety classes on a recurring basis. Sure, there are guys on the water like guys on the road who aren't insured, but maybe it will reduce the dummy factor?
10-11-2007 10:18 PM
Wayne25 It doesn't take extra money to do the enforcement either. If the local existing marine police would set up randomly at the entrance to a marina and check the operators as they came in and enforce the existing laws, the stupidity would grind to a holt. Do the same thing at the usual spots where stupid things happen ( you know the places) and enforce the law, stupidity would stop. I shouldn't say stupidity. I should say lack of respect.
10-11-2007 08:57 PM
joeasburyp I think we (most) except purist..., are "stink pot's" at times: thinking about that most "bone head things I've done, were under power!" Yes that means more than one.
The difference, IMHO, is that all boating is sailing, and all boats sailed untill the late 1890's, therefore, we have one hell of a standard to live up to. Boating is a new term. This term has led to the mass production of afforable boats. Which leads to that "mass" thing.
Boat - OR - Sail,
Most ships, open sea or harbour, have an education to the craft. I.E. ( nav, tides, planning, thinking, ect..) Most sailors I know, like to read about these's (-)'s and master.
Boater's, ("stinkpots, megayatchs, sailors, cargo, ect") are a hazarad to sailing...we all need to look out. I would rather, give way and have a story to tell than repair my boat.
I am the only "Sailboat" at my marina in Dover, NH. So, the local pub is right there. And I would have to say that all "stink pots" are very considerable. Those that use the lauch, well that is a different and oppisite opinion.

I see it as a matter of Pride.

I can be the "BEST" sailor I can and accept and reaserch, untill I can.

Having driving a few PWC, My IQ drop's...there fun! But, one needs to be by themselfs. Fast boat, jetski, whatever, to fast to be close, without education.

Law's will not do any good, until we enforce the one's we already have. So, let's spend more money making more laws that we will never enforce. That big lake(can't spell unless I look up) southern NH, has just passed law's...difference being that most homes on the lake are 1/2 million or more, and the laws are enforced.

I sail in the coast of NH, and see more enforcement officers, and see that most do enforce or rules.

To end, I think that well all need to keep the tradition of sailing to far port's,
and am sure you have not heard of 3-4 Ft motor boats sailing across an ocean. Yet, Small sailboats, year after year, come from points far and wide.

With that, I have never meet a person from France, In NH, that came with the bottle of wine, IN a Bayliner 19Ft bowrider. A Flicka, yup, I can see that.

Thankyou to all "sailors out there...! ... Lead by Example" .

New to me Tartan 27, #461
09-26-2007 11:39 AM
Lancer28 Zeydon Z-60
09-26-2007 11:23 AM
thedudeistoocool A little off topic but I gotta ask

Lancer what kind of boat is your avatar - I think I want one !
09-26-2007 11:22 AM
Lancer28 I forgot to mention since I cut them free, I left the huge ugly wad of 1000 wraps around the cleats on the dock just so they knew it didn't happen on accident.
09-26-2007 11:12 AM
Lancer28 Good one! We had a lady in a pontoon boat who likes to park in the transient parking in the exact same space every time (at the very end of the pier). Let me add that there is no "special" parking at the transient dock; it is just first-come-first-serve business. She's just anal about where to park because it is easy to get into.

She is about 55 and a total skedge looking person - comes back to find a little 185 Sea Ray parked in "her space" so she docks in the next slip over and starts bitching. This is where I started paying attention as she looks around with her drunk husband (didn't see me sitting in the cockpit reading a magazine) and unites the sea ray, pushing it out into the cove where the wind blew it across and grounded it on the beach.

I was so mad that the park rangers said, "we didn't see it so we can't do anything," I went over at about 3AM and cut them free letting them float across and ground on the beach too. the best part was not hearing her screaming that woke me a few hours later the next morning, or the crowd that was watching from the marina (pointing and laughing), but that nobody would go over and help them pull it back off the beach. It was about 9AM before they were floating again.

That's my little "bad guy" story. Similar to what you should have done with that fishing boat!
09-26-2007 10:50 AM
chucklesR I've got a sailing buddy who has been sailing since childhood, taught me to sail, but certainly not how to skipper a boat.
His main bit of fun is to put his boat on collision courses with stink boaters and force them to give way, even (or expecially) if he has to tack to do it - in his view this teachs them the rules of the road.
As to licensing and registration - I prefer enforcement - but since the world runs on taxes and American's are adverse to paying for the goverment they want (because we are too busy paying for what we get) you can't have enforcement without rules, and people/resources to enforce them.
My slip owners are USCG Aux members who patrol weekly, both in the upper 70's and still very active; they just switched from SB to PB three years ago. They can't ticket, have no law enforcement powers at all, I'd change that and let them at least give a ticket.

And the next time I see a fishing boat anchored in the channel at the mouth or the Magothy River I will swear I'll run the dinghy back and cut his anchor rode. I had to dodge three boats this past weekend. Wonder what the law enforcement folks would do, ticket me, or thank me for clearing an obvious (and oblivious) hazard to navigation.
Okay, ranting done....
09-13-2007 06:19 PM
Lancer28 Has anyone seen Idiocracy the movie yet? You've got to watch this!!!! Reminded me of this thread A LOT.
09-12-2007 02:58 AM
Sasha_V I sail in Victoria, Australia, and boat licenses weer introduced for all vessels that had a motor some years back. Some say the license is too easy to get, some say it is slanted or "wrong"...but generally, out on the water, it seems to have made a marked improvement.

80% of licenses are issued as a result of a two day "course" woth an exam at the end of it, and a big emphasis on good seamanship and ongoing studies. You cannot always mandate courtesy, but you can spend a couple of days drilling it into poeple that it is expected and that everyone will get along far better if no one is acting like an ass.

The number of hardcore idiots has dropped and most local sea rules are respected most of the time. Sure, some people decide to speed in a marina, but it quickly becomes apparent that the first time you take off liek a bat out of hell, your marina mates or admin will come and have a friendly chat with you about why that is a bad idea....The next time you do it, you will have the water police waiting at the dock as you return. And the thing that is understood is that this is part of being a good boater and is not ratting out someone.

It has gotten a whole lot more pleasent on the water, we are rescuing fewer people from themselves when I am on duty with the Coast Guard and we have only been abused by a drunk who needed a tow home once in the last 20 months. A majority of folks now do their real drinking after tying the boat up for the night.

Interestingly enough, radio manners and protocol have also improved over the last three years, even on the unregulated 27meg channel. People just seem to have a changed attitude slightly. And there are still tons of boats, boat sails are booming, and people are having fun on the water, if anything, more and more young families with kids can be seen out there, whether fishing, sailing or bouncing around at a high rate of knots in open water.

This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome