|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|08-02-2011 08:44 AM|
Never buy Raymarine products - go for one of the other brands. I've had so much trouble trying to get my systems fixed it's taken over a year now, and still counting. Their customer service team never does anything on time, they promise to send engineers, and they never come, and there's no logical reason why it would take so long to get things fixed.
Really disappointing - must be down to their going into administration and never quite recovering - honestly urge you to stay well clear.
|11-14-2009 11:45 PM|
for all those suckers who bought an s1 or an x5 i would be willing to dispose of it for you. i would even pay shipping to me.
if any one has one they removed in working condition or even with just a broken wheel drive let me know. i dont have an auto pilot and even the admiral pilot does not work too well. single handing is fine but no auto pilot or even a wheel lock its gets harder.
|11-14-2009 11:25 PM|
|negrini||I think wheel pilots had very limited use, on sheltered waters or easy winds, for instance. Global changes on weather patterns, waves, winds and currents, etc ... put even the old belief on hydraulic drives robustness on check, with a growing demand for repair. Wheel drives have an even narrower use nowadays, so consider a below deck drive instead a X-5 wheel ....|
|11-14-2009 08:59 PM|
I need to expand a little on that. The software is great. Everything they say about the system not needing a rudder sensor is true. The board has an accelerometer chip on it which it uses to sense the reaction to the application of steering. It really works well. The good news ends there.
The wheel steering unit is rubbish. The motor housings break more often than not, and the gearbox will not handle your 38 footer, as it doesn't handle mine. I've been through two of them so far. This unit would be OK for a power boat or a small yacht, but the weather helm and swell-steering that you get on a bigger boat breaks the steering system.
Don't bother with the angst of a broken autopilot. Don't bother with the x-5.
|03-28-2008 01:50 AM|
I tend to think - the more everything works together the better the system is. But comparing issues with some brands and lack of follow on support is the most crucial... who wants to be stuck in the S Pacific suddenly to hear "Nope we no longer support your gear:
The protocol is easier to understand than ASCII - but most brands somehow try to make the cabling to be a if you want it you need "x - engineer" to interface it..
This is the issue I see with Raymarine... the shelve more actual working products to force brand loyalty to go with the next big thing...
|03-28-2008 01:28 AM|
I'm not condemning the interfacing of GPS with autopilot, but I can see it leading to sloppy habits and an overreliance on one technology that I've seen with my own eyes being "skittish". Consider that a fluxgate compass might provide a "yawing" reading, telling the pilot to steer in broad S tracks, but if the GPS hiccups and adds half a degree to latitude right at the point you are feeding info to the pilot, your boat could take a hard turn to left or right with all sails up.
I have seen GPSes do this if they lose their satellite lock or if there's some sort of solar flare or "test outage". By contrast, a fluxgate might swing 20 degrees, but hardly ever 90.
Now, one answer might be this device:
ComNav Vector G2 GPS Satellite Compass w/NMEA - 11210001 - Compasses - Electronics - NavStore - Your Pro Marine Source - Detail
but for that price I could buy a tiller and a lifetime supply of shock cord.
Of course, the belt and suspenders route is to use a wind vane when sailing, and to save the autopilot for motoring or motor sailing.
|03-27-2008 07:19 PM|
Originally Posted by Valiente View Post
Speed is very important, because when autopilot knows what speed the boat has, it can react differently to various conditions based on that (though on sailboats speed range is fairly narrow).
In addition, connecting autopilot to GPS makes it easier to set GPS's own fluxgate compass - just stay on a course, and press "sync" button. There are a few more good uses where autopilot - GPS linkage comes in handy.
Incidentally, I am quite pleased with S1G autopilot so far, which I can't say about the Garmin chartplotter, that died for no reason less than 6 months from purchase (and only after a few weeks of use).
|03-27-2008 03:28 AM|
|03-27-2008 02:04 AM|
Originally Posted by Hartley18 View Post
|03-27-2008 01:43 AM|
There is a small problem though - no-one would buy it!
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|