SailNet Community banner
  • SailNet is a forum community dedicated to Sailing enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about sailing, modifications, classifieds, troubleshooting, repairs, reviews, maintenance, and more!

Composting Marine Heads

5K views 25 replies 15 participants last post by  genieskip 
#1 ·
I have seen two liveaboard vessels with newly installed "Air Head" marine composting toilets, but I haven't found anyone with experience to evaluate their performance over time with more than short term use. Are there any "Air Head" users out there with advice? Let us know,-Aythya crew
 
#2 ·
Oh man!

I saw one of these yesterday. It was misused / poorly maintained and it reeked so bad the entire inside of the yacht was spoiled.

I've spoke to a couple of other owners that say the pee-bottle catcher is good for about 80 wizzes (and I heard something about SUGAR in the tank to reduce smell). They also told me you don't have to empty one for years, if only a couple used it. The only BAD feedback I really heard about them is the vent line, and if you catach a breeze from it, you'll want to barf. I have heard nothign about parts, but I would check on the little fan in there and see how easy it looks to replace.

I don't know man. It's a toss up in my book; do I want a sloshing tank of goop I can flush out into the sea or pump at a station when I'm sailing inland, or ferry around 30 pounds of years old poo?
 
#4 ·
I don't know man. It's a toss up in my book; do I want a sloshing tank of goop I can flush out into the sea or pump at a station when I'm sailing inland, or ferry around 30 pounds of years old poo?
The claim of the composting toilet manufacturers is that the solid waste decomposes in a matter of days into a non-odorous powder that can be disposed of (in the garden if you have one) without any unpleasantness.
Where does the "years old poo" idea come from?
 
#3 ·
I don't have one. Many of my fellow Gemini owners have installed them and I've seen (and not smelled :) ) them. I want one, and will install one once I get to it on my list of upgrades. I just wish someone made a marine head with a house sized seat.

The simple fact is two less holes/through hulls in my boat is to be applauded. Properly installed these can not smell, clog or break, and especially can not sink your boat. Who can say that about a holding tank?
 
#6 ·
Well, it is poo.... no matter how you look at it, dried or wet, powdered or fresh squeezed. They also say you shouldn't have to empty it for years if you were so inclined, which was why I mentioned years of it.

Personally, I'm perfectly happy not bagging it to take home to a garden. Cavemen pooped in the water and washed off, I bet. Fish poop in the water, land animals and fowl poop there too. Why is people poop so much worse, that I would need to bag it up and cart it home in the trunk of our Benz or Subaru? Fertilizer can be bought from a store, and if it was the money saving issue, you can compost in your own backyard in most municipalities.

With that said, I'm sure there is a market for the toilet with people who don't want to put two holes for a head in the hull, have to move the boat from it's slip to go to the pumping station or actually sail it and dump the head tank, or simply feel like the composting idea is contributing to the green world.

Bottom line IMO, to each their own!
 
#7 ·
Old thread.

I know this is an old thread but I'm faced with a partially finished head/holding tank installation I inherited from the previous owner. I have a holding tank and two thru-hulls with a vent. No toilet, diaphram pump, anti-siphon or y valves. I've been reading about composting heads, specifically the Natures head http://www.naturehead.net

I figure it would be nice to get rid of two holes in my boat and this system is basically a head and storage system all in one. I have a 25 foot boat I plan to liveaboard when I finish the refit and I would gain a lot of space under the v-berth where the tank and valves are.

Does anyone have any updated experience with these units?
They do seem expensive for what they are, basically a bucket with two compartments to separate solids and liquids with a hook up for a vent on the side. Thanks Brandon
 
#9 ·
The sanitizing systems actually produce cleaner effluent than the municipal sewer systems are allowed to dump into the water. So they are allowed the same privileges as the municipalities except in NDZ's which at least are supposed to be places where insufficient flow/dillution make no dischatges acceptable...though this NDZ designation is being widely abused by "greens" and political hacks.
 
#10 ·
So my poo needs to be "cleaner" than that sea-lion poo; so when the fish eat everyones poo (yes fish eat LOTS of poo) the "clean" poo I send overboard is the preferred poo? :D :D

I understand the need to treat/clean large volumes like from municipal sweage treatment; but isn't the sewage from recreational boats a drop in the ocean by comparison?
 
#13 ·
So my poo needs to be "cleaner" than that sea-lion poo; so when the fish eat everyones poo (yes fish eat LOTS of poo) the "clean" poo I send overboard is the preferred poo? :D :D
For the fish its a good source of food. I read an article about a study operation that raised pigs on human waste and then fed the pig waste to catfish and finally used the catfish waste as fertilizer. I am not sure what pork raised on crap would taste like and I hope I never have to know but there is quite a bit of nutrient left after our inefficient digestion systems get done with our food.

Now the cholera and other waste born pathogens I would much rather not have to swim with.
 
#12 ·
I agree

Some have said they don't stink inside the boat, I imagine if you get anywhere near the vent you'd wish you hadn't, but that's also true for standard holding tanks. I'm going to sleep on it, it's either that or a tank above the waterline with a gravity drain. I just like not having to worry about the thru-hulls and the storage I'd pick up.

I'd like to hear opinions, especially first hand experience. Brandon
 
#16 ·
Huguley3 has it exactly correct. Most (not all but the vast majority) infections do not travel between species. That is why everyone one is so bent out of shape about swine flue and avian flue. they had to mutate to become dangerous to people. The stuff that lives in your crap can certainly live in my eyes so if I have a choice I would rather have sea lion poop in my water than human. As sort of an aside this is why it is such a criminal idea to give human antibiotics to animals, but that is for another post.

So on to COMPOSTING TOILETS. Even when flushing overboard when offshore the average head smells like - not to put too fine a point on it - crap after about a week. I figure at least part of the reason for this is the lack of air flow so maybe a continual fan would do the job.

One very major issue that I have not seen discussed is maintenace of the composting toliets relative to the pump ten times throw the switch pump some more turn the switch etc etc etc. If the composting toliet eliminates one overflow a year with the sweet smell of urine permiating the bilge it is worth whatever the cost.

The Air Head website says that they can be adapted to an existing holding tank for the liquid portion. Has anyone done this or know of anyone who has? Has anyone replaced one head on a multi head boat with a composter? If so what is your feelings.

Thanks all sk
 
#17 ·
My 2 Cents

My boat needed a holding tank, and was about to install one when my wife saw the Airhead toilet. She loves the idea. Me not so much. I wanted a conventional system (holding tank) since I know what I'm in for.

I did some reading, and found this:
Joseph Jenkins, Inc. - The LOVEABLE LOO

Airhead and Nature's Head people say that if you keep the urine and most liquids out, you get no smell.

Well, I thought I'd try an experiment. I set up a 5 gallon bucket in the bathroom of my house to use. It was funny. We just remodeled the bathroom: new wide pine floor, new toilet & sinks curtains & paint..and now an orange bucket. Toilet was off-limits except to pee. I also got some coco husks bricks to mix. To start, I slightly hydrated about one gallon of the coco husks as the composting medium, then after every use, a cup gets added. We stir the bucket with a stick every few days. This was late winter, all windows closed all the time. I was kind of hoping the experiment would stink up the house so we could be done with it. I was surprised that there was no smell what so ever. Not kidding! I was expecting it to stink at first, and kept the bathroom door closed (no vent fan) to let the stink collect, but there was no smell. After you go, a cup of the husks and the smell disappears as quick as flushing the toilet. Smell would not be a reason to doubt this system. I must admit that it somehow seems "grosser"...not flushing it away and out. The stirring is a little gross too, no smell or anything, it doesn't even look gross, just the idea is unsettling.

We're going to try it on the boat. I've glassed over the two hull holes, and we'll see. We are still undecided as to which we get, the Airhead or the Nature's Head. At this point, if it were me I'd stick with the 5 gallon bucket but I've been told that females might appreciate the urine separating feature of the commercial units.

-Preserved.
 
#18 ·
Well, I notice a year and a half has gone by since I originally posted this question and no one has replied that actually has a composting head on their own vessel. I'm very impressed with your bold experiment, Preservedkillick, and I'm not surprised by the lack of smell. I have a friend with a composting head in his home and there is no smell there either. I suspect that those with problems are either supporting anerobic bacteria growth or they are not keeping the composting material as dry as required. As for the concerns posted by people regarding Vibrio Cholera, or any spread of pathogens, this potential problem is decreased by the use of a composting head as opposed to the use of water as a transporting medium to dispose of waste, which is the method by which pathogens such as Vibrio cholera are transmitted. I'm still interested in hearing direct information from cruisers who actually have long term experinece with a composting head abord their own vessel. 'take care and joy, Aythya crew
 
#20 ·
I buy into the composting idea, but here is my concern. Since there's a seperate reservoir for the urine, which isn't all that big, and I'm cruising in a no-discharge zone how do I get rid of it? Am I suppose to go empty it on shore? If I'm at my berth and the reservoir is full I would find it a bit weird walking down the dock past all the boats & people to go dump my urine in the toilet.

We had an Envirolette composting toilet at the cottage years ago and everything got mixed together, no seperate reservoir, but this toilet was way too big for a boat. It worked well, no smell - go fuss.
 
#21 · (Edited)
Faced with a problem in my after head last year (I don't know why J boats decided to put two heads in a 40 footer, but they did) I decided to take a chance on a composting head. I figured I'd keep one head with the usual holding tanks setup and try a composter for the other, thus having a backup if either failed. When I cruised to Nova Scotia last summer the one that failed was the standard head. A guest of the PO had dropped a sanitary product into the thing and jammed it up - a fact I didn't discover till I took the system apart.

The jammed head made the whole forward part of the boat practically unusable. Of course, we didn't know the system was jammed and at one point I looked at the holding tank and saw it was bulging in all directions, really ready to burst. I had visions of the thing exploding and me running the boat ashore, leaving it there, never to return. So, while offshore, I had to open the deck fitting, resulting in a two foot high gyser of you know what. It was at that moment that I decided I would never have a holding tank system on the boat ever again as long as I lived.

Meanwhile the after head was happily doing its job, without odor or problems. I realized that if there ever was a problem I would be able to take care of it offshore by removing the bottom part that holds the "end " product, tie a line to it and dip it over the side a few times, till clean. Much easier way to deal with a problem than the myriad hoses, valves, tanks etc of the standard system.

I am a total convert to the composting head solution and last year removed all signs of the holding tank era, using clorox to try to remove the lingering odors. This spring I took the compost (and it was compost by spring) out of the after head and dumped it in the woods - I'm still too chicken (and afraid of the wife) to put it in the flower garden.

Last week I sealed the sea cocks for both heads, installed the second Air Head, and the space previously taken by two holding tanks, assorted hoses, valves, pumps, etc has been put to much better use (the forward 20 gallon holding tank that nearly burst has been replaced by an auxiliary 20 gallon diesel tank that increases my fuel capacity by 40%)

I never experienced any odor problem. I did not use the supplied 12 volt fan, not wanting the constant drain on the batteries. Instead I use solar vents that keep the air moving without taxing the electrical system. Although I only used the composter for the second half of last summer, I never had odor problems of the kind I saw (smelled?) on my boats in the past. Incidentally, I have no connection, financial or otherwise, to any composting head maker. I just love the product, at least compared with what else out there for the purpose.

More than half a century ago Dick Nye, owner of the legendary Carina asked Olin Stevens advice on what to bring on a Transatlantic race. Olin said " a stout oak board with an 8" hole and a 100 pound bag of coal". Dick wondered about that but decided to follow the advice anyway. Sure enough it was cold as all getout on the race and all 100 pounds of coal went into the stove. The stout oak board? It had to be jury rigged to the pushpit when the head died hafway across. Wise words from a wise man.
 
#22 · (Edited)
I'm glad you did that little experiment, preservedkillick, because it reinforces what I've discovered about my AirHead. There is no smell. I thought that when I opened the sealed flap to drop the end product into the lower compartment I would get a strong smell coming out. Never happened. First, I followed the manufacturer's recommendation and put a large coffee filter above the trap door. That way when you flip the trap door and the filter and contents disappear into the lower tank there is nothing left in the upper area to need cleaning. Close the trap door and turn the stirring crank a couple of times and you are done. According to the manufacturer it is good for about 80 uses for solids.

As far as urine is concerned, it is not quite the same as poop. The pathogens that are found in feces are not as prevalent in urine, and cholera and suchlike are not spread by urine as far as I know. (I am not a medical professional so I could be wrong). If I am not close to shore or if I don't have female guests aboard I tend to pee over the side (while clipped in any kind of rough seas - I know a high percentage of drowned men are recovered with their flies open). If the bottle has any contents I dump it before going into the harbor. I have also walked to the marina head with a bottle. It is opaque so not many know what's in it and it comes with stopper. And unlike the strong chemical contents of portapotty heads, the marina management shouldn't have a beef.

I have sat near the solar vent that exhausts the air and never smelled anything. Like most other things on a boat a composting head will take care of you if you take care of it. Keep it clean, keep it filled with moist peat moss, keep it vented. I can't think of anything that could go wrong, but if something did go wrong, it would be easy to deal with because it is a very simple machine.
 
#23 ·
Composting heads...

I am tempted to install a composting head on my boat. We had one for 4 years in our home (with 3 children included)in AK years ago. No odor problems but the little thing didn't care for too much liquid. Beer drinkers were sent outside behind the woodshed. Warm temps sure aid the composting procedures. Always struck me more as a living breathing biology experiment than a sewage system. If nothing else, those heads provoke conversations.
 
#24 ·
I like the concept and idea of using the 40 tank for fuel or water instead, (my boat is still under construction so I can still easily make those choices).

I have read a number of threads on this subject but haven't seen the answer to the question "what happens when you take a 1-2 wk. trip with 4-6 people?"

Bill
 
#26 · (Edited)
If you are on a 2 week cruise with 6 people, chances are that you will exceed the capacity of a composting head for solid matter. You would exceed the capacity of a normal holding tanks as well so you would have to do something about that too. Easy if you are in local waters with pumpout stations available. Last year in Nova scotia we had the problem of not finding pumpout stations all over and had to wait till our fourth port to get to one. Same with most of the rest of the world. What people who have holding tanks in those situations do is go far enough offshore to comply with regulations and pump out manually, a tedious job at best.

As I said in an earlier entry, a composting head is a very simple machine. Just go more than three miles offshore, (I would recommend 10 - you'll probably be that far out during part of the trip) remove the bottom container from the head, dump it overboard, put more peat moss in and put it back in use. Remember, it is legal to pump directly overboard when more than three miles offshore. This wouldn't work too well if you are just working your way along the shore from marina to marina, but then you'd probably be using the marina's heads and showers anyway and wouldn't tax your system.

Look, nothing's perfect. In boating everything is a compromise. I prefer something which is extremely simple in use (and repair) to something which has so many pumps, hoses, tanks valves etc. that repair is at best difficult and often impossible underway as well as expensive and messy ashore.
 
#25 ·
Bill,

There were a few posts I had read in the Gemini group regarding over-using the toilet. No perfect answers. One person talked about a week long trip with six people, and the head did fine, but needed a few weeks to "catch up" if I remember correctly.

I suppose you could just dump the contents overboard if out past any legal limits. They cost a thousand bucks, but the bottom of the unit is really just a bucket.
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top