|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|02-12-2009 06:56 PM|
I want to hear a different opinion from the one I am reading in my "out of date guides."
Frankly, I'm not sure which route I'm inclined to pursue. I'm not in love with the idea of a heavy displacement hull, but I want a boat that is comfortable to sail and hates being upside down.
What are some of the fin keel boats with comparable angles of positive stability?
|02-12-2009 05:10 PM|
With all due respect, I suggest that you quit listening to the mythology and looking at out of date guides to bluewater boats. The reality is that many of the heavy displacement, full keel cruisers actually have substantially smaller angles of positive stability than modern fin keel boats, and few on the list of offshore cruisers above achieve 140 degrees of positive righting moment.
While a heavier displacement boat with narrower beam, more volume underwater, fuller keel, etc. is one valid way to go, the majority of offshore cruisers out there do not meet that description. But if that is the route that you are inclined to pursue, with your budget I suggest that you see if you can find a good clean Kelly Peterson 44 or 46.
|02-12-2009 03:39 PM|
Thanks for the book recommendation. I'd definitely like to get a different perspective. It makes sense to me to have a boat that wants to roll back up from a knockdown to 140 degrees, but that characteristic only seems to be possible with those massive full keels and huge displacements.
Like you, Elzaar, I'm still in the "sorting out all the information" stage.
|02-12-2009 03:04 PM|
Welcome to the search. Try doing a forum search of "bluewater." I tried to post a link, but haven't chattered enough to qualify.
There is another link for best books. I have the books you've listed, but you may also want to check out the 2nd edition of Beth Leonard's "The Voyager's Handbook." She wrote the first edition after completing a circumnavigation in a modified keel ketch (Shannon), but the 2nd edition is after they have been cruising in a steel-hull fin keel cutter, so it has a good bit of insight into the advantages/disadvantages of various arrangements.
I am still in my search for the boat, so I can't offer much assistance beyond offering resources I've been using.
|02-12-2009 02:35 PM|
|AjariBonten||By the way; we seem to be browsing the same market, except that I'm 3 - 5 years away from a purchase at that price point.|
|02-12-2009 02:34 PM|
|AjariBonten||I would be hesitant about the large windows on most pilot houses|
|02-12-2009 02:28 PM|
I'll look at those. I don't really want to spend more than about $150K at this point.
Is a pilothouse appropriate for ocean cruising? I really do like the Pan Oceanic?
|02-12-2009 12:33 PM|
|AjariBonten||I'd add Tayana 42 to that list as well|
|02-12-2009 12:20 PM|
What's your price range and desired length?
Based on the example you cited in your post, I'll assume you're looking for something in the 40-45' range. That being the case, I'd personally also check out the following:
Southern Cross 39
Cabo Rico 38/41
Hans Christian 41/43
That oughta keep you busy for a while!
|02-12-2009 11:30 AM|
|Melrna||See sticky at the beginning of this forum.|
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|