|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|06-05-2009 07:47 PM|
|AKscooter||I am not sure about the RCMP...but I can tell ya about the coasties in Valdez Alaska. I am in my whaler trolling.......they come flying up in their RIB with a man on the fifty and several guys with m16's. Safety inspection my arse. I am tired of how this country has gone the way of authoritarianism. Land of the free my arse. No you cannot board my home. I am tired of thinking of the "children". No, it is about the money...that is all it is.|
|06-05-2009 11:05 AM|
Originally Posted by Cruisingdad View Post
I didn't want to re-post your entire comment, but, well put, well said and I agree!!!
|06-05-2009 10:22 AM|
Also, and God help me for ever quoting this guy; Rush Limbaugh says that "we didn't become a great nation by acting fearful, but by being free, and that we won't stay great by ceasing to be free. "
Again, I applaud John for knowing where the line in the sand is, and holding to it.
|06-05-2009 12:12 AM|
Needlessly inconveniencing Joe Citizen may make some people feel safer, but all the real bad people are just sitting back laughing.
Having said that, I think there are some distinctions to be made... I find US Customs and Border Protection to be the worst offender. I've never been boarded by the Coast Guard but in all my other dealings with them both north and south of the border I've found them polite, humble, and focused on the task at hand. I have no doubt that, in the event they were to detect criminal wrongdoing, those same fresh-faced youngsters would spring into deadly and effective action, but it's all the more impressive they don't feel a need to swagger over their capability. In personal experience, and I don't doubt this is true for many of you, I've nearly always found those with the most swagger are some of the least capable (in any arena).
If I were a haji I'd smirk and play the game with the tough guys... I'd worry about the friendly grandmotherly looking types like Diana Dean instead. And if I wasn't doing anything wrong, I'd be a lot more proud of my country with someone like that welcoming me back than someone packing a lot of attitude and very little intellect.
|06-04-2009 11:44 PM|
|06-04-2009 10:02 PM|
|camaraderie||John...yes. I am sure. It was a Supreme court decision. And Scotty is correct...it is USCG only...not anyone else. Of course...if they discover something...then a warrant might be issued for the cops to execute.|
|06-04-2009 09:32 PM|
Originally Posted by johnvye View Post
as much sense that it makes the police cant come aboard with out a warrant or permission but the USCG can. here in baltimore city we have 4 sets of cops to deal with, the USCG, the marine police who get their power from the state DOT, the DNR, and baltimore city police who have no jurisdiction except what they get from the guns they carry. the city has a bunch of boats and about the only thing they can do is for drinking, although they try to do more. most of the city cops just let you do your thing, and if they have a problem they call in the marine police. there is one who harassed me a bunch of times over my stickers when i bought my boat. i had sent in the title and a bill of sale for the boat and i had a copy of the bill of sale. every time he saw me he threatened to impound my boat, even when under the 30 days allowed to title it. then when a screw up happened and i got a letter extending the 30 days due to issues at DNR of losing my old title ( who does boat titles and stickers ) he kept harassing me.
welcome the the 21st century when the .gov thinks they are all mighty
|06-04-2009 09:14 PM|
It's my recollection that courts have ruled that the U.S.C.G. has authority to do safety inspections, certainly while the boat is underway, and that includes authority to go down below and check your head and fire extinguishers. I frankly don't know what their authority is while at anchor. Both Border Patrol and Coast Guard have broad authority to search vessels that have nexus to the border.
Bosun, are you still there?
|06-04-2009 09:10 PM|
Originally Posted by johnvye View Post
So put your boat on the market and move to New York City! Most of all, quit yer' bitchin'. Maybe you ought to try the Red Sea or the Gulf of Aden. I here Somalia is nice this time of year.
You know, if I was trying to smuggle contraband or some type of terrorist device into the US, I'd think that I'd get a sailboat to do it on. I'd put a nice big Canadian flag on the stern, try to look stupidly offended at every opportunity, and rely on the fact that security forces have to deal with Canadians all the time. (My apologies to the otherwise rational Canadians out there; you know whom you are.)
|06-04-2009 09:04 PM|
In defense of boardings, which are nothing more than a hassle when you come right down to it, it's not the tenth of September 2001 anymore. I'd imagine that if you're the RCMP or the USCG your attitude might justifiably be, "not on my watch."
Admittedly, we've become spoiled over the years by the open borders between the two nations. From an American's perspective, it's been interesting. Now Canada joins the list of mental institutions requiring a clearance to visit. (just kidding!)
Be polite and they'll go away. Be polite and when the heat in on to meet their quota they'll board the ***** they remember. And be very glad that when Johnny Jihad figures the best way to get into the US with his stash of cocaine to fund his operations, that the Mounties are there, with those fifty caliber thru-hull makers.
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|