SailNet Community - Reply to Topic
Thread: would you buy a "holed" boat? Reply to Thread
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the SailNet Community forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
Please note: After entering 3 characters a list of Usernames already in use will appear and the list will disappear once a valid Username is entered.

User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:


Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.

  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

Click here to view the posting rules you are bound to when clicking the
'Submit Reply' button below

  Topic Review (Newest First)
05-28-2012 02:45 PM
Re: would you buy a "holed" boat?

I would have no problem buying a boat with a hole in it. But that isn't to say I would even take a free boat with a hole. Depending on the extent of the repairs, and the other things wrong with it, while it may be possible to fix a boat from any condition, that doesn't mean it is economical to do so.

For instance, post Katrina my uncles Trip 40 was found in the parking lot of our yacht club. The boat was literly in three pieces, the keel snapped off, the transom was crushed by a tree, and the mast was wrapped around a light pole. This is all reparable damage, but a good used trip was $40,000 and the repair bill would have been more than a new one.

My fathers boat, an Irwin 54' looked pretty good. Just a lot of road rash, the dolphin striker pulled out of the boat, and a broken rudder. We passed on buying it back from the insurance company, but a guy bout it at auction for around $20,000. Since then it has had over $400,000 spet restoring it. While a good boat of the same year would cost 250-300. But as the work progressed they kept finding one more thing wrong with it....

On the other hand, a member of my club just bought a new j-22. It was at nationals this year and got T-boned. Went to Donnie Brennon (US Olympic teams boats right) for a $6,000 repair, and now the boat is in perfect shape.

To me it really depends on the extends of the damage, the cost of the repair, AND the amount a comparable boat in good condition would cost. Sometimes free boats really aren't free.
05-28-2012 01:51 PM
Re: would you buy a "holed" boat?

Buying a damaged boat would not put me off at all, but the whole point of buying a damaged boat is to get it for nothing, or next to nothing. Most times these boats are not economic to repair because it includes labor costs.

Lots of people abandon boats and the yards get them for free. Rather than repair a hole, I'd look for a good boat that just needs some clean up that is selling at auction at a boat yard. I wanted to bid on a Tartan 10. I was out of town for the auction. The fellow got it dirt cheap, cleaned it, repainted the boot and cove stripes, gave it some bottom paint and had a very nice boat for cheap.

For repair work, I have had my best success restoring a trailerable boat at my home.

Buying a project boat? I'd think seriously about investing in a trailer or modifying a used trailer for my purposes. Getting a new one built is expensive though. If you see a boat with a good galvanized trailer it is worth a lot. I once saw a triple axle trailer carrying a Catalina 30. It was a great idea and for someone keeping a boat for a long time, it saves a lot on storage. That boat is a bit too slow for me, but the idea has merit.

Doing your own work makes a difference but it has to be done fast. Yard fees will eat you alive. Moving the boat to you residence might be expensive in the short term, but cheap in the long term. Buying a set of poppets or building or modifying a trailer makes this easier too. Factor in the cost, but also consider the value of being able to store your boat at home. Even a boat on a trailer stored at a marina is cheaper than normal dry storage. They can stuff a trailer between two other boats and the yard is using space it could not otherwise use.

Any fiberglass boat can be repaired. I would avoid wooden boats, cold molded, or strip planked, etc.

The key is to pick a good boat to start with. A LeCompte Medalist is a good choice because the hulls are strong. Sabres are well built boats.

In some cases stripping out the entire interior is faster than trying to repair something.

A bigger boat? It is better to have help to get the hole fixed. Finding help is difficult and slow. Workers don't care about your yard fees, they charge a lot and don't work quickly. So the best help would be people you hire directly.

Then try to launch it quickly. It is cheaper to keep a boat in the water than in dry storage. Finish off the inside later.
05-28-2012 12:47 PM
Re: would you buy a "holed" boat?

denise, I once had a serious bid in on a Sabre 38 that had been storm damaged, a big flap knocked open by a seawall or piling after a hurricane.

What you have to do is figure the price of a proper repair, the inconvenience of it, the likelihood of making it right (often 100% with fiberglass) and then adjust the price. In my case, I'm pretty damn sure the guy who outbid me was nuts, there were just too many uncertainties about what the total repair would get into.

Way before that, I walked away from a "bargain" on an Albin Nimbus, where the PO had quite literally taken a chain saw to one of the ribs in the hull, apparently for better bilge drainage. I'm sure it was repairable, but I really didn't want to know how having one rib stiffer, or not as stiff, as the others might or might not affect the keel and the hull. And I didn't want to know where else his chainsaw might have gone.

Now a boat that looked DROPPED...I'd also pass on that one, no real telling where there's broken glass fibers inside the hull as things flexed.

It really all just depends on the uncertainties and the costs. Hey, maybe there's a reality TV show to be had in this. You know, like American Pickers and Pawn Stars and the storage locker buyers? "Treasure Ship!" :-)
05-27-2012 06:58 PM
Re: would you buy a "holed" boat?

Originally Posted by Mauryd View Post
I've seen some major resto projects in progress at a shop last week. I was shown 2 big powerboats. A 38' go fast boat and a 30' Fishing boat.

They cut the aft end of the fishing boat right off about 3'-4' forward into the boat. They totally put back a new one on that they made and 2 huge outboards were hung on it. You would never know. Looks perfect.

The go fast boat had the whole bottom delam at high speed and sunk in California. These guys bought the salvage and toally reworked the transom and put a brand new bottom on her with with fiberglass mat, fiberglass cloth, resin, filler, gelcoat, and hard work. Looks brand new.

It's amazing what you can do with fiberglass.

I am doing some small hole repair on a Hobie 16 that I own. One's around softball sized. Then a couple of golfball sized holes as well. Very easy so far. They say the hard part is the prep. So I have that part all done. I start laying glass very soon. Hopefully next week.

I found a site called US Composites. They have very inexpensive resins, fillers, and gelcoat. Try them at: Fiberglass , Composites, Carbon Fiber - U.S. Composites, Inc.. You can find great deals on fiberglass cloth on ebay. Search: "fiberglass cloth"

I'm telling everyone I know doing fiberglass repair about these guys. I have no idea if you are considering doing it yourself or not but you never know. Hope this helps.

Best Regards,

I use Mertons in Massachusetts. I'll check out these other guys though. Thanks for the tip Maury.
05-27-2012 06:55 PM
Re: would you buy a "holed" boat?

Originally Posted by Sailormann View Post
No - it will cost so much money to repair properly that you could buy two or three other used boats instead. If you don't repair it properly you may well drown.
That is nonsense. Any fiberglass boat can be easily, EASILY, repaired. But I can understand why you would be frightened off. It takes some skill, as well as confidence, and more importantly gumption. If you are lacking in these, you would be better off hiring someone with these qualities.

Now let us consider cost, the other area where you are badly mistaken. First, you can find holed boats for NOTHING. So the cost to repair is your only cost. That is much less than buying two or three other used boats, which will also need work--that much is certain.

If anyone is considering repairing a damaged boat. Start with a smaller boat, and when you find out how easy or hard, depending on your point of view, you can decided to take on bigger jobs.

Let me make one more point. There are lots of boats that were not designed all the great, but you can make changes to them to make them great boats. For example, changing dead-lights to portlights, installing a spade rudder, lengthening a boat or adding a scoop transom.

So ignore the above poster. He is one of the "Can't do it people, who has to convince everyone else not to do something, simply because he can't." There is nothing you can't do, up to and including building a boat from scratch.

10-19-2009 10:30 PM
would you buy a "holed" boat?
No - it will cost so much money to repair properly that you could buy two or three other used boats instead. If you don't repair it properly you may well drown.
10-16-2009 11:23 PM
Mauryd You should be able to fix up the wooden boat with 2 rolls of duct tape and 3 gallons of paint. I don't even think you could tell it was not new. Mind you, you will want to prep the surface really well. Maybe wash it or something...I don't know but the point is should'nt take more than $50 bucks. Looks like a bunch of minor cosmetic work to me.

10-16-2009 07:27 PM
SundancerKid Our organisation turned the rusted out hulk lying on the bottom in the first picture back into the ship in the second picture. Anything is possible with time, money and a little skill.
10-16-2009 02:16 PM
mitiempo Or perhaps you'd like something in more traditional wood construction.
10-16-2009 02:08 PM
mitiempo No hole reportedly - just a weeping cutlass bearing that was ignored for a couple of decades.
This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome