|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|03-10-2012 03:15 PM|
Re: Laptop as a Chart Plotter
Originally Posted by brokesailor View Post
You have to decide whether or not you want independent systems which would provide you backup or whether you want an integrated system.
$37 will buy you a BU-353 GPS puck for your laptop software, don't know how you'd integrate the AIS, though.
|03-10-2012 09:48 AM|
Re: Laptop as a Chart Plotter
I have a "A" Series Raymarine Chartplotter in the cockpit with Raymarine Instrumentation and the Raymarine Class B AIS. I would like to also setup a Navigation Computer at the Nav Station with possibly MaxSea Nav software. How do I connect the computer to the NMEA 0183 network? Or am I better off just connecting the laptop to an independent handheld GPS?
|12-11-2011 08:01 AM|
Originally Posted by night0wl View Post
added dock with second display for cockpit and transparent touchscreen overlay
|07-29-2011 02:37 PM|
Originally Posted by brak View Post
First, it is important to understand that NOAA raster charts (RNCs) are exact copies of the NOAA paper charts. In fact, they are produced by scanning the paper chart. Still, in July 2011, the paper charts are the basis from which raster charts are produced.
Next, there is at present no central electronic database from which either raster (RNCs) or vector charts (ENCs) are produced. Let me say that again, since there is so much misunderstanding on this point: there is no central database from which charts are now automatically produced.
To be absolutely sure of my understanding, I verified this today with two senior NOAA officers deeply involved in hydrographic cartography.
There is, in fact, a major effort underway to develop a central electronic database from which both RNC and ENC charts would be generated, but it is fully two years or more down the road before deployment. At present, RNCs and ENCs are produced by two separate offices within NOAA, though they collaborate closely in an attempt to avoid errors.
Potentially, of course, ENCs may contain many layers of information and these may be captured in a central database from which the charts could be produced. This is the goal, at least, if not the present reality.
1. RNC (raster charts) are exact copies of the underlying paper charts. They are images of the paper charts...no more, no less.
2. Paper charts are the controlling "database" from which charts are produced at present.
3. At present, there is no underlying electronic database from which charts are automatically produced.
4. ENC (vector charts) are not necessarily identical to either the paper charts or their images (the raster charts). Therefore, they may contain errors of omission and of commission.
One thing I can agree with Brak about: NOAA charts -- both ENC and RNC -- are excellent products which NOAA takes great care in producing.
That these are available to us for downloading at any time, and free of charge, is a wonderful benefit we get from NOAA's hard work.
|07-27-2011 09:42 PM|
Originally Posted by Maine Sail View Post
At this point NOAA paper charts are generated from the same electronic data as those you download and use with navigation software. So while there is a benefit of redundancy with paper charts, there is no benefit of "better information" anymore.
|07-27-2011 08:14 PM|
Too true MS. I love my little Garmin handheld. Its been utterly reliable though admittedly I only use it for heading and lat/long. That said we still have a back up and like you I carry paper. Indeed , offshore I'll still plot to paper even though the positioning is done electronically. Quite frankly its part of the enjoyment.
I do wonder though how , in your case, Garmin could get it so wrong. It s nott as if they do their own mapping.
|07-27-2011 08:55 AM|
Why I still carry paper...
Over the years, been using chart plotters since 1997, I have come across many errors and omitted pieces of data from the NOAA cartography. This is why I still carry paper and do my best to mix that and my plotters information with "local knowledge". When cruising my home waters paper only comes out in thick fog but it is still always on-board.
We also suffered a lightning strike last year which took out four devices not plugged into ANYTHING. Essentially all electronic gear on-board, including my laptop, and disconnected back up GPS devices, was fried.
This is but one example of a Garmin error....
0.2 nm Scale:
0.3 nm Scale - Hey Where Did The Land Go??:
0.5 nm Scale - Land, Land, Bueller, Bueller.........:
0.8 nm Scale - Oh there you are..........
Check out the 108 foot deep spot on the 0.3 & 0.4 nm scales.... Oh yeah that's a hill not a harbor.....
I find it amusing when people pay such homage to a particular brand like they are infallible or something. None of them are and they ALL make mistakes. I love my Gamin stuff but it is FAR from perfect...
|07-27-2011 12:45 AM|
|aeventyr60||The other problem with the "all in one screens" is that the data boxes are so small it's impossible to read from a distance. Maybe my eyes are just getting worse.......|
|07-26-2011 05:04 PM|
Originally Posted by daddyhobbit View Post
Going back to Jim's original post, here's my experience:
GPS and Navigation Software Options
|07-26-2011 09:53 AM|
Originally Posted by jimmoser View Post
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|