|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|08-23-2011 10:35 PM|
|fryewe||Looked through the whole thread again...wanted to point out that heading is where the ship is pointing, and can be measured in either true or magnetic, and course is the direction you are trying to go. For example, your course can be 090M, and you can be heading 095M when you check the instrument you are using to steer...and your course can be 090M, and your heading could be 085M when you check the instrument. The course didn't change because you are still trying to go 090M. Your heading is always changing, wandering about the course you are trying to steer for reasons noted earlier.|
|08-23-2011 10:29 PM|
|fryewe||Course or heading can be either magnetic or true. Consistency is important in keeping the log. Every log book should have instructions for keeping it. If the log keeper is directed to observe the compass and enter his reading of the magnetic compass at the logging interval, or GPS in true heading, that is okay, but it's not the instantaneous heading that is important for DR. The helmsman, or the autopilot or wind vane, is directed to steer a course about which there is some wander. That course should be the DR course, and in my view the log should reflect whatever the helmsman is using to steer and monitor the autopilot and/or wind vane performance by, be it magnetic or true. Even if the ordered course is not along the desired track or route because you are avoiding something, or because you can't lay a desired course due to wind direction and have to fall off, at the point and time that happens, the navigator or log keeper should note the time, and mark the DR track at the time of the turn. From that point, he lays out the new DR in the new ORDERED direction. The most important reasons for keeping a DR plot are predictive...that is, to look ahead at where you are TRYING to go to prevent foul water, weather, traffic, and for efficiency in making way toward your destination.|
|08-23-2011 06:15 PM|
|AdamLein||fryewe: everything you said seems correct, but if the log book said "Course = whatever", then that's not a compass reading. You said yourself that the compass gives an accurate indication of heading. So either the logbook was filled in incorrectly, or for some reason the navigator filled in his magnetic course instead of his true course.|
|08-22-2011 06:15 PM|
DR is maintained along the steered course from fix to fix, but DR can be "reset" to an EP if you have a good one. DR is a plot of the track you have steered, are steering, and will steer at the speed you observe on your log, and distance observed on your knot log. EP is estimated position, a "best guess" based on all navigational factors you have at hand, including historical info. In general, DR error can be estimated as a percentage of your speed, a few degrees of course error due to compass error or helmsman capabilities, historical or observed set and drift, leeway, or calibration errors. By knowing these errors, and applying them along your track, you can build a "wedge" (expanding with errors as time since last fix increases) within which you are quite certain your current actual position is. Then if, for example, you have a sounding that corresponds to a depth you can correlate within the wedge you will estimate that to be a much more accurate position than the DR location. If you want to reset your DR to that ESTIMATED position, that's the navigator's or captain's call. When you get a fix, you always reset your DR to that FIXED position. You can then evaluate your error between DR and the fix and determine whether the factors you use in determining your EPs (or building your wedge) were good.
In this age of near continuous fixes, DR and EP are being used less and less. If GPS is not available for whatever reason, and you're away from visual navigation aids, making log entries allowing for accurate DRing and good EP estimates from noon sight to noon sight, or other fix source and interval, will be invaluable.
|08-22-2011 05:30 PM|
|08-21-2011 08:02 PM|
You seem to understand the problem from your OP, and are simply trying to decide what to plot.
Seems to me the problem unfolds this way: If the logbook entries are 004M and 264M, they were taken from the compass. Doesn't have to be that way, but generally, the compass is your most reliable heading instrument. Could have the GPS display in magnetic, or the chart plotter, but you can get fix right off the display if you have good signal, and that makes no sense for the stated problem. If you are manually plotting, as the post sez, and leeway is known (how? as a known characteristic of the vessel when it is hard on the wind in 18 knots, which is the only way I can think of unless you are comparing compass heading against course on the GPS), then DR would be plotted along the mag course 004, and EP would be plotted at the end of a vector from your starting point along mag direction 009, at a distance equal to your estimate of distance traveled from the starting point.
When you tack to 264M, plot your DR along the 264M course from your 1400 DR position.
When you get a fix, reset your position to that fix, evaluating its quality, and start a new DR from that fix.
Dead reckoning is a simple integrated plot of course using the instrument you steer by and the speed you read on your log. Estimated positions include leeway, current effects not measured but historically observed, and other factors.
|08-20-2011 02:48 PM|
AdamLein, so I would plot on the chart 004M and 264M, right?
|08-20-2011 02:43 PM|
|kwindancer||Thanks for responding to my question and the Power Squadron recommendation. I'll look them up. I'm actually taking a home study seminar as I travel a lot for work. I've been able to understand 90 percent of the material except for those few questions. This forum has been very helpful, and most of the responses have been educational. I hope that by me asking questions, it will be educational for the rest.|
|08-19-2011 02:44 PM|
I think you are saying,
"Course" is the direction you actually made good, not the direction you steered, which is referred to as "heading". Therefore the log already accounted for leeway.
I would agree.
|08-19-2011 02:16 PM|
what course are you taking?
From this and your other thread it sounds like you're in a sink-or-swim course where you're not getting much instructor help.
You might be better off to find your local Squadron of the United States Power Squadrons. The national site is http://usps.org Although the name says "power squadrons" it is a sail and power educational organization and you should be able to rely on your instructor to help you sort out issues like these, and get for sure the right answers and reasoning rather than a bunch of educated, or maybe not, guesses.
|This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.|