SailNet Community - Reply to Topic
Thread: Novice at sailing and first time buyer. Reply to Thread
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the SailNet Community forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
Please note: After entering 3 characters a list of Usernames already in use will appear and the list will disappear once a valid Username is entered.

User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:


Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.

  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

Click here to view the posting rules you are bound to when clicking the
'Submit Reply' button below

  Topic Review (Newest First)
12-29-2011 03:56 PM
Originally Posted by AdamLein View Post
It was only very recently that I was in your shoes. The best advice that I ignored was to spend some time on OPBs ("other peoples' boats") before buying my own.

Right now you are asking some good questions but in many cases there is not one right answer. Instead, it will depend heavily on what you want in a boat. Right now, you have no idea what you want in a boat, besides the (correct) knowledge that sailing is awesome and you are damn well sure you want a sailboat.

So really what you should do is see what a few different boats are like. Maybe there is a local sailing club you can join, though most of them only have sailing dinghies. Look for a club or co-op that has boats in the 22-30 foot range. Around here we have a sailing co-op where for vastly less than the price of owning a boat, you get lots of time with their boats, and they will teach you a lot about maintaining a boat. If you can find something like that in your area, I would jump on it.

Another option is to get on a racing crew. "But I'm not all that interested in racing," you may say, as I did. Whatever. Pretend it's just a "daysailing crew". You will get to see how a boat's deck is organized and how her interior is laid out. The latter is especially important as it's almost impossible to change. Talk to the skipper and other skippers about why he made the decisions he did, what he likes about his boat, what he would change. Be open to the possibility that you will not be permanent crew on a single boat; seeing lots of boats is what's best for you right now. No amount of looking at pictures of boats and their interiors on the internet gives you as much information as five minutes in the cabin of a boat.

In they end you may be restricted by your budget, as I was. In my case, I got a reasonably good boat and it has taken me several years to figure out what I liked about it and what rubbed me the wrong way about it. Now I'm in a much better position to shop for my next boat, but even though I got a really inexpensive boat, the annual cost has added up quite a bit, and it sure would be great to have all that cash to put as a down payment on a boat I *know* I want.
Three years ago I was in the exact place you are right now. What make? What size? What draft? What engine? and on and on it goes. Adam's advice is as sound as your going to get. There is no hurry to buy a boat right now is there? Some of the questions you are asking sound like my questions early in the game. Pretty much everyone has the perfect boat. Perfect for them of course. Take your time, do your research and sail as much as you can on as many different boats as you can before you buy. I sailed for a few years, crewing for different people on different boats and learned tons of information about what I wanted or didn't want. Go to the marina's and wander, offer to help if someone is working one their boat even if you don't know them. Eventually all your questions will be answered and your new boat will come to you when you least expect it. I am actually glad I didn't buy the boat I originally wanted. By the time I was done figuring out what i wanted I ended up buying a 38 foot boat. Not a length for newbies but you wont be a newbie if get the experience before you buy and your purchase will probably be more long term than fixing up, selling and trading up. Beware of fixer uppers too. If they weren't maintained, then they weren't treated very good and there is too many hidden surprises that turn out bad and waste your money. Anyway, read Adam's advice again. My advice is for you to listen closely to Adam's advice.
12-28-2011 10:46 PM
gmerrill In one of the post the person advised spending time with someone on another boat. Sailors are really friendly people and eager to share their passion for sailing. My experience is I started out with a 16 foot compac legacy. Took all of 10 minutes to set up. Easy to get in and out and you could haul it with just about any size car. A very well built boat and stable. I learned basic skills in the beginning and soon I was learning about how to shape a sail so on and so on. Did I make some mistakes. You betcha. But they were small mistakes because I was on a small boat. I have since moved up to a precision 23 and am looking forward to this level of sailing. My last piece of advice. Buy a good but that is in demand, even if you have to pay more. One day you ll have to sell it and it won't sit around for long. Wish you well and you have chosen a hobby worth your time and passion

10-09-2011 12:14 AM
TakeFive I started looking exactly 2 years ago thinking fall was "the time to buy" and expecting to have a boat in a few weeks. As we started shopping around and realized that every boat is a compromise and many of the boats were waterlogged junk, we realized it would be a complicated decision. We spent almost every weekend over the entire winter shopping (through snowstorms in the northeast) and purchased at the very end of March. So we shopped for 6 months. We actually enjoyed the process. Some here have shopped for multiple years, but if you want to be on the water by next spring, it's not necessary to shop that long.

My advice is take your time, see as many boats as you can, and try to envision what are the most important things you will want to do both outside and inside the boat. We kept getting pushed up in size, thinking we had to fit the whole family for a week long trip. Ultimately we realized that 95% of our sailing would be daysails in very protected waters, we didn't care about racing, and the kids were old enough and disinterested enough that it would just be me and my wife. So we got a boat with a comfortable cockpit, but enough cabin to do an occasional weekend, and small enough to maneuver easily in river currents.

My life is such that we may never do a week long cruise, but if I do I'll spend a couple thousand to charter a larger boat. My experience sailing our pocket cruiser will give me the skills to do bareboat chartering when that time comes.

Personally, I don't think that boat prices fluctuate all that much between seasons. The well cared for boats have owners that will pay for winter storage while they wait for the right offer. If a guy's desperate to save winter storage costs, he may be too short on cash to have maintained the boat properly. Remember, also, that often people move up in springtime, so new boats may come on the market at that time with the owners wanting to unload quickly. But, bottom line, it seems to be a buyer's market right now, and I doubt that will change by spring. But don't get your hopes up too much about low prices - well cared for boats will still command more money than project boats. If you want a project boat, those fixer-uppers that may have sold for $2,000-$3,000 before might be had for free now. The risk is that you could end up with something that costs you more to fix up than it will ever be worth.
10-07-2011 11:29 AM
emoney You know, one of the hardest questions to answer is the one you've posed. As a self reported "newbie" to sailing, understand that there's so much personal choice involved in this decision, that it might be wiser to start with something that doesn't necessarily meet all of your wishes, but that gives you the on-water experience and fluidity that boat ownership proffers. Having said all that, if you were say my brother or friend and asked me the same questions you've posed, I'd recommend that you shop for the best condition 22'-23' boat that you can find that comes on a trailer. 7700lb towing should allow for that with ease and safety in mind. I'd recommend this to them because as is usually the case, the odds are you'll be looking to "trade-up" a lot sooner than you think. Now, I know the response will come, "why settle if you know you're going to trade up anyway?", but bear with me as I expound. You'll probably want to "trade up" even if you purchase a 30 footer because at this moment, there's no way to be 100% sure of what your needs and/or wants really are. By starting with the smaller boat, already on a trailer, you obviously cut down the winter storage issues, you also allow for the portability that you desire, and you've picked a boat that allows you a wide berth opportunity of relative safety to learn the nuances of sailing (which will be ongoing as you progress, btw). With that in mind, finding a 22' trailerable sailboat in Autumn for around $2k should be a breeze, but make sure someone that knows sailboats exclusively is involved with checking her out before purchase.

As to the question, "should I wait until Spring?", I'm of the opinion, "no". Yes, someone is going to be willing to sell their boat a little cheaper because they can save the "haul-out/winter storage" fees that they know they will be facing. Also, spending the winter getting to know your new boat, doing minor on-board projects, etc., will be invaluable in your learning. Whatever you decide, keep us posted and good luck.
10-07-2011 09:28 AM
JimsCAL Some thoughts and comments.

NADA and BUCValu have listings for the values of used boats. But their values are not very accurate due to limited data and use of depreciation curves rather than real market data. Values of used boats vary tremendously based on condition, and the sites don't take this into account very well.

The largest boat you can reasonably trailer is about 25 foot. That would work for hauling and storage for the winter to save a bit of money, and maybe a trip to cruise some waters farther from home, but forget about doing this every time you sail.

The pluses and minuses about inboard and outboard engines have been pretty well outlined in previous posts. With regard to power, 1.5 to 2 HP per 1000 lbs is a decent rule of thumb. Less than that is fine for motoring in calm water, but not enough for pushing the boat against wind and waves. More will not buy you much speed with a displacement hull, but might help a bit when motoring in heavier weather.
10-07-2011 12:36 AM
xhevi Haha..I hear you.
My land rover discovery weights about the same not including the offroad add ons, and it has decent horse power and hauls a** thru rock, mud, sand, water over the hood and up steep inclines, like no other truck I have driven, IMO best offroad toy.
But I have no experience towing big heavy trailers and I quoted the owners manual " 7700lbs with brakes on trailer"
maybe its time to install the heavy duty breake kit that I bought months ago and that's sitting on my storage.
But back to boats... is there like a "KBB" for boats? Would be good to know what's the actual value, before considering of buying any boat.
10-06-2011 11:47 PM
seabreeze_97 For what a slip would run you, you could grab an old honkin big truck that'll tow 8000lb. Trailer brakes? What trailer brakes? We don't need no steenkin' trailer brakes. My old RamCharger weighs over 5000lb, and even though it's a 2wd, (they also had 4wd), it tows and pulls up wet ramps beautifully thanks to that weight and a big footprint. Parts are cheap and it's easy to work on. It has big brakes that get the job done. Just something else to consider.
10-06-2011 11:13 PM
xhevi Just checked that my Discovery will tow up to 7700lb; trailer with brakes and low gear
That will cost me about a dollar a mile and it will not take me anyfaster where I want to go....
Or...... could I raise the sails and let the boat push my truck instead??
This trailer able idea is getting colder by the
10-06-2011 10:42 PM
xhevi I am in NYC. I will be sailing, hopefully, around Long Island, up and down Hudson river or up and down eastern coast.
The idea for a trailer able boat is to be able to store in land during winter to avoid expensive marinas around here. Or take a week off, haul it say to boston or maryland or further, sail in the waters there then haul it back. But from the advice I am getting here seems that its not the way to go, at least not for the reasons I wanted a trailer able boat. It not a

If I had the space, I would not mind a project boat... but believe me....even finding a parking spot is not not that I was gonna store my boat on the allready give a hard time then I try to change spark plugs.

But anyway...I am taking a sailing class this weekend, out in the water Saturday and sunday, so Monday I might have a better idea.
I will check the clubs around but the reason i want to own a boat is to just get on the boat and get away for a weekend if I felt like it, with out much planing or reservation.
Your sugestions are already helping. Thanks all.
10-06-2011 09:29 PM
BostonSailor Where in the northeast are you? There are two good sailing clubs in Boston Harbor that have a wide range of sailboats - day sailors to 40' offshore boats you can take for a week long cruise. Sailing there for a season on a range of boats would help you better understand what you like/want. And you'll spend way more time sailing since you won't have to spend a minute maintaining the boats . Check out Boston Sailing Center and Boston Harbor Sailing Club. Join for a season and sail as much as you can for no other cost.
This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome