SailNet Community - Reply to Topic
Thread: Mystery Shutdown (at just the wrong time!) Reply to Thread
Send Trackbacks to (Separate multiple URLs with spaces) :
Post Icons
You may choose an icon for your message from the following list:

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the SailNet Community forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
Please note: After entering 3 characters a list of Usernames already in use will appear and the list will disappear once a valid Username is entered.

User Name:
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.


Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.

Email Address:


Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.

  Additional Options
Miscellaneous Options

Click here to view the posting rules you are bound to when clicking the
'Submit Reply' button below

  Topic Review (Newest First)
11-18-2011 08:06 AM
LakeSuperiorGeezer Need to do something as the engine is likely to quit when you need it the most.
11-17-2011 10:10 AM
saillowey When I had issues with the coil, it acted exactly like a fuel system issue. It would run, then start to sputter at an increasing rate, then shut down. There is an easy check the coil. Look at the bottom of the coil. If it's not flat, but rounded out, you need a new coil. The heat has distorted it to a point it's pushed out the weakest point. If it's round, take it down. When you buy the next one, mount it on the bulkhead. I'm sure I can look up which one I bought. I know it was an Echlin model from Napa. Most of the parts can be had locally if you have a Napa store. I know I also bought the wires and cap from there as well. Seem to me the cap was also used on a 1974 Chevy Vega.

Good Luck
11-16-2011 11:18 AM
LakeSuperiorGeezer Seems like you are trying to do trouble shooting without any resources so have to be a little more creative. The engine is running now without a problem so it is not possible to troubleshoot. You are just guessing. The following is not a definitive for sure diagnostic, but if the following criteria are not met, you know where the problem is. Here is one think you can try. Is the fuel tank located above the carburetor? If so the fuel pump could be dead and the engine would still run because of gravity feed. If the fuel tank is below the carburetor, pull the fitting at carburetor and slip a hose on it making sure it will not leak, maybe need a clamp for this. Becareful with matching hose size. Use a rag or better use a container to capture any fuel, or use a rag under a container. There is the fire and explosion problem with gasoline. Turn on the ignition and see if there are several quarts of fuel pumped per minute into a container. This could vary with the exact model of Facet pump. Find the pump model number and I can look it up is you like If the carburetor is below the fuel tank, fuel will pour into the bilge if you loosen the fitting so you must turn the fuel off at the tank or disconnect the tank until you have the hose on the delivery pipe. You can also check any fittings before the filters to check for debris. If the filters are after the pump, check the fitting where the line goes into the pump.

Another thing to try is take the center wire from the distributor and place it half an inch from metal. Tie or tape down if needed, but make it half an inch. If there is no smell of gasoline around the engine, crank and see if you get a nice fat spark. Sometimes when an ignition is going bad, there is enough spart to start the engine, but it looks weak, jumps a quarter inch or less and is likely to quit any time. Be careful with the spark as these modern high energy systems can deliver enough amps to be lethal. Also, magnetos are very dangerous. My dad knew a fellow killed by a magneto. By the way, try the spark test first before opening any gasoline lines. Less chance of a fire
11-16-2011 09:04 AM
dabnis To rule out a possible fuel problem you might try hooking up a clean outboard tank with fresh fuel in it. If fuel delivery is not the problem, disconnect the tach wire and try another coil after double checking all electrical connections and possibly replacing all the high voltage wiring. Let us know what you find.

11-16-2011 08:28 AM
CapnBilll A safer way to test spark is to hold a neon light next to the spark plug wire.

My boat once had these symtoms, and after disassembling fuel system I found a mass of fiberglass fibers stuck in the fuel pickup tube. I would take a good hard look at ignition system as the tach reading comes from there. One of the two coil or tach may be bad.
11-16-2011 06:00 AM
tommays Vent could be clogged BUT if it was going under water it would draw a LOT of water into the fuel tank
11-15-2011 09:12 PM
Originally Posted by JimPendoley View Post
Hi All,
Had a nerve wracking shutdown of my A4 today while sailing in gusty conditions. Symptoms were a "Clunk" and then a stuttering shutdown. Upon restart, I noticed my tach stopped reading. I've converted to an electronic ignition years ago. The engine ran a minute or two then shut down again. Oil pressure fine and so was the temp, alternator charging normally. I was motor sailing in boisterous conditions and a little on my ear. I would have thought it was sediment in the tank stirred up, but I do have a fuel water separator and I add gas stabilizer with every fill. This happened more than half a dozen times and it's a problem today because I have to exit a particularly long and tortured channel in the next few days.
The engine did finally stay running, but I kept the throttle low and the boat flat-still no tach. Is this suggestive of a coil breaking down? Prop seems clear, but I'm not going overboard to check-its November in New England after water int the bilge.
Any suggestions on how to test the coil greatly appreciated.
Coil is a possibility, do you have a spare, or a friend with an A-4 who would loan you their coil for a test run? The tach giving up the ghost could suggest something. However, when the coil heats up and stops functioning I believe it shuts down the engine as if the ignition where switched off.

I would also check the fuel vent to see if the spiders have been at it. Insects/arachnids will build a home and it wills stop or slow the tank from letting in air as fuel is burned off. The engine will shut down, then, later restart as of nothing happened.

Are you getting full power? Can you make hull speed? Try running the engine under load at the dock to recreate the problem.
11-15-2011 07:20 PM
JimPendoley OK all,
I appreciate the suggestions of everyone, being in a remote spot in late autumn its reassuring to know folks are out there.

Alls not lost though-hanging on the anchor and eating like a king in a very deserted and pretty part of the world is not all bad...

After lots of thinking-this is what I am imagining happened: on a deep heel (+20 degrees) the fuel vent goes underwater-its mounted high on the port stern counter but would likely submerge beyond 20 degrees of heel-pump can't draw fuel, heats up trying to suck fuel from a closed system and does not blow the fuse (if there is a fuse and I'm not sure there is), heats up the wiring on the ignition circuit and blows the tach. Boat flattens out and the engine runs normally-but tach is shot. It seems explicable-the facett pumps used to recommend a 20 amp fuse but now recommend a five amp fuse for this reason-
Tomorrow, I'm going to start the engine (it ran for charging purposes for a long time today) and put my hand over the fuel vent. If the engine shuts down relatively quickly, I think it's problem solved. If it does shut down, just to confirm the vacuum problem, I'll crack the fuel filler to see if it picks up fuel again.

Does this sound plausible? It does to me, but I had a glass of wine with dinner....
11-15-2011 06:15 PM
LakeSuperiorGeezer Whether you decide to to any testing or not, keep a good anchor ready going through that long and tortured channel you mentioned. If you decide to do some testing, buy a vacuum and fuel pressure tester that measures to about 10 PSI and vacuum to 30 inches mercury. This is not for fuel injection pressure measurements, which are ten times what this gauge measures. This tester is for engines with carburetors. The vacuum tester can be used for setting up low idle jet, just adjust jet for maximum RPM while adling. Be sure to clamp all fittings as you do not want gasoline in the bilge. The pressure gauge should read about 3.5 PSI for a good fuel pump. I prefer engine driven mechanical pumps as I think they are more reliable than electric.

Ignition spark tester goes inline between spark coil and distributor. It flashes when there is a spark. If no spark that really narrows the problem down to the electronic ignition system.

You can search online for these items.
11-15-2011 02:39 PM
JimPendoley Thanks everyone. Rob, I did go to Moyer site, very familiar with them-but there is a delay between when you join and when you can post. Engine starts normally now, but still no tach. Reading the Moyer forum, there is a thread about Facett fuel pumps failing gradually and the fuse not blowing, but the wiring heating up and creating a soldering effect that will take out the ignition circuit. Well, right now my engine seems to run reliably, but the tach is dead. I think I'll disconnect the tach in case it was shorting to the coil and interrupting the circuit. Any other insights greatly appreciated.
This thread has more than 10 replies. Click here to review the whole thread.

Posting Rules  
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On

For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome