|Topic Review (Newest First)|
|12-20-2011 08:43 AM|
|SimonV||I vote for the Dutchman Boom brake I have one and its is fail safe. Should I get another boat it is one item I will make sure I get the same.|
|12-20-2011 03:08 AM|
Originally Posted by berwick1 View Post
The last yacht (36' - St. Anna) had the traditional type boom brake and it worked great.
This yacht is 46' and the mainsail is about the limit for the wichard gybe easy.
I prefer the simplicity of adding or subtracting a loop and I have a 4:1 to add tension.
It works a treat and in light breeze, I sometimes have to push the boom across - thats OK, better than the unintensional gybe in heavy conditions.
I do believe you would be very happy with whatever system you choose.
|12-19-2011 09:38 PM|
I have a Wichard, the kind where you weave a loop of line through it 1 to 3 times.
I don't have enough experience with it yet, but it's worked in the light-ish winds I've been in.
|12-19-2011 07:37 PM|
|berwick1||Ok thanks, St Anna, why did you choose the Wichard gybe easy on the new boat vice the Fleming?|
|12-19-2011 08:48 AM|
I had installed the Dutchman on my last boat and added it to the new boat. I lead it back to a winch in the cockpit. Easy to adjust tension to freeze the boom or let it jybe. Love it! No more crash jybes.
|12-19-2011 06:13 AM|
|St Anna||I had a fleming 'boom brake' on the last yacht and a few months ago, I put in a wichard gybe easy on this yacht. I am very happy with this set up as I mostly sail solo and it is safe and solid. I can adjust the tension in the line.|
|12-18-2011 01:39 PM|
As a former rescue climber I would recommend any system that you can 'precisely' adjust the amount of friction that controls the 'pay-out' of the control line ... and not have to depend on the variable friction under varying wet/load conditions --- usually needing a human brain. That would in my mind more favor the Scott or the Fleming.
Id avoid a "figure-8' for any 'large' area mainsail as 1. you will have difficulty in putting 'enough wraps' on the the '8". 2. if you do get an overwrap with 'multiple' wraps its going to be a major job to get it to 'release'. 3 'strength' vs. a full loaded large mainsail is probably going to be a 'minimum'. The 'figure-8' would be 'worse' for over-wraps; the rescue-8 has 'ears' to lessen the potential of 'overwraps': Rescue 8 : Rock Climbing Gear : Rockclimbing.com
Of course any of the friction type 'brakes' are infinitely better than a rigid 'preventer' which do not allow for any 'impact' from an out of control boom or for a boom that gets 'dipped' into the water.
FWIW - I use the Wichard 'ladder type' on a ~450 sq. ft. mainsail, but find that it needs constant adjustment to get the 'right amount' of 'slip'. The Wichard supplied 'rope' is VERY stiff (kernmantel?) and is quite hard to set up precise friction.
|12-18-2011 10:36 AM|
I know a lot of people use preventers (Sail safe anti jibe boom preventer or a purchase to an anchor point) etc. I am leaning towards boom brakes, looked at the Wichard gybe easy (or make my own with a figure 8 descender). I have researched the Dutchman and the Walder but am curious and trying to find out more about the Scott boomlock and the new Fleming Gybomatic. Anyone out there using one of the latter two, and does anyone have any videos of them in use while jibing?