Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: CT/ Long Island Sound
Thanked 34 Times in 33 Posts
Rep Power: 16
[quote=6string]I do not have the rule book with me at this time to verify my comments. But as I recall, you can not force the windward boat into a luff regardless of how high you (the leward boat) can sail.
The leeward boat can sail as high as she likes, provided she's on her proper course. A Soling on an upwind leg, for example, might routinely head 15º higher than a Catalina 30 with old sails. Tough luck, Catalina, if you find a Soling to your leeward.
If you are carrying speed enough to come through the leeside, wouldn't you want to continue to foot off slightly and get a safe leeward.
If you're already sailing faster than another boat and going through their lee without having to foot off, why would you want to foot off and lose distance to windward?
Seems to me that would be faster and a bit more prudent.
Not if you want the windward boat to tack towards the "wrong" side of the course, and by taking him up you can make him tack. If you foot off and pull away, he may be tempted to continue along with you to the favored side of the course
If you wanted to tack that should have happened sooner, prior to the overlap.
Right. The leeward boat doesn't want to tack. He's headed towards the side of the course he wants to be on. He wants to mess up the windward boat and make him tack.
There's a lot going on in this situation, and the "facts" of the case are vague enough to allow for some gray areas. Did anyone (such as A?) do his turns for not keeping clear? Why did B hit A? Did B do any turns for having contact with another boat? Was there damage? Was it severe (in 20 knots of wind, maybe it was.) Proper course is another gray area. What might be the proper course for one vessel could be a luffing impossibility for another. Was there a protest? What did the PC decide? With such a big bucket of worms as this thread brings up, you may want to take up fishing instead.