Instead of trying to protect myself by beefing up my boat insurance and owning life rafts, I concentrated my efforts on strengthening the hull and modifying her systems until I could consider the boat as its own life raft. This was due partly to budget constraints and partly to my philosophy of maintaining self-sufficiency at sea. To begin with, prior to my second circumnavigation, I installed a watertight collision bulkhead in the bow section under the V-berth. Though I wasn't at first seeking outright positive buoyancy for my boat—or even imagining it was possible to achieve that—over the years I gradually modified most of my 28-foot Pearson Triton's storage areas into watertight lockers so that if the boat is ever holed in any of those areas, the flooding will be contained.
Working from the bow aft, here's a list of the watertight lockers that I've created on board Atom:
Once the majority of lockers were converted to watertight compartments, I wondered if I had incidentally achieved positive buoyancy on a boat with a gross displacement around 9,700 pounds. By making estimates of the amounts of fiberglass, lead, anchors and chains, other metals, woods, foam deck core, tools and miscellaneous gear, and calculating their respective buoyancy factors (see table below), I came up with a figure of 86.5 cubic feet of watertight locker volume needed to float the boat with the decks awash. (Imagine cutting up a foam block 10-feet by nine-feet by one-foot thick and placing the pieces throughout the boat). More flotation is needed to compensate for the reduced volume of lockers loaded with gear and a safety factor of at least 20 percent should be included.
I then calculated that my watertight lockers, which have rubber gasket seals have an approximate volume of 95 cubic feet. I have not included any partial watertight bulkheads unsealed at the tops, which might be flooded over, or the water tanks and the numerous water cans because they may at any time be full of freshwater. I plan next to add closed cell bunk cushions well strapped down to create another significant source of buoyancy. Obviously, the more flotation the better. A boat that floats with the cabin top awash is impossible to repair and pump out at sea.
At this point I figure Atom will float briefly even if she were holed in one of the few remaining areas of the hull which are not contained by watertight lockers. I say briefly, because although I've taken care to provide a good seal, I cannot be sure how fast the water will leak past the gaskets into the lockers.
Another consideration is ensuring a level and stable platform after flooding. If all buoyancy chambers are near to or below the waterline, a flooded boat that heeled over could become unstable as the water simply moved to the low side of the boat. Having both chain locker and all cockpit lockers sealed to deck level greatly increases the stability of a flooded hull. The ideal situation is to have both ends of the boat sealed and a U-shaped area of flotation following the hull shape in the center sections of the boat.
I plan to further improve Atom's flooded stability as well as her insulation by adding sheets of rigid foam in unused areas along the interior sides of the boat above the waterline and under the deck. These blocks can be glued in place, or where easier hull access is needed, they can be attached by straps or Velcro. While Atom does not yet have an adequate safety factor of reserve buoyancy for me to state conclusively that she will remain afloat when holed, she is certainly far less likely to sink in most flooding situations because of her extensive watertight compartments. Certainly, I sail with less anxiety now when plowing through heaving seas at six knots at night in mid-ocean.
Other systems available to retrofit your boat for positive buoyancy include inflatable flotation bags that can activate when submerged by water. However, there are problems with active systems such as flotation bags, principally that they may activate inadvertently, or worse, fail to activate when needed.
Relatively heavy, narrow beamed, low freeboard boats like mine are difficult to retrofit for positive buoyancy. Wooden boats and boats constructed with a cored hull have an obvious advantage in this area. Modern, beamy boats with large interior volume are well-suited for built-in flotation. The most efficient way to achieve this is during the boat's design and construction. Cored hulls, watertight lockers, and strategically placed rigid foam in new boats should be the rule rather than the exception. The additional cost could be partially offset by lower insurance rates, and the increased safety factor is priceless. Many governments around the world are now or will soon require pleasure craft to have positive buoyancy. Given the loss of life of those who abandon partially flooded boats they felt were in danger of sinking, it is clear that positive buoyancy is highly desirable. Hopefully, boat builders will not wait for bureaucrats to legislate what is a common sense requirement—an unsinkable boat.
|The Following User Says Thank You to James Baldwin For This Useful Post:||
|Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Making Your Boat Unsinkable||CarpeAquam||Gear & Maintenance||35||05-29-2013 02:43 AM|
|Book Review (Unsinkable)||davidpm||General Discussion (sailing related)||0||01-26-2012 09:18 PM|
|the concept of unsinkable yachts||Johnno||Boat Review and Purchase Forum||61||03-24-2011 08:58 AM|
|Unsinkable||dupek||General Discussion (sailing related)||44||09-18-2010 04:15 PM|
|Unsinkable Havana sailing on (Chicago Sun-Times)||NewsReader||News Feeds||0||02-11-2007 01:15 AM|