"Anhinga" St. Augustine
When I chartered in the BVI-first time there, I was worried about this too. As it turns out, it is quite fun to sit around the saloon table with your crew and spread out the paper charts to make your cruising plans. It is also fun to put into practice the old paralell rules and dividers. It really is the easiest place to get away with going "old school". As the other have said, if you want a chart plotter, an Iphone or Ipad with Nav App will be more than enough.