SailNet Community banner
1 - 17 of 17 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I have a new AE 38. I have 3 Batteries. Bank 1 is the house with a 200 amp and a 100 amp. Bank 2 has a 200 amp Engine Battery.

I have a 110 amp generator.

I have a meter that shows how many amps have been used in each bank and how many amps are being either consumed or when the engine is on or I am plugged into shore power, how many amps are going into the battery.

My problem is that i never seem to have much more than 10 amps positive going into either battery bank when I am charging. And unless I run the engine for 3 or 4 hours I can't get the batteries up to even close to 100% charged. And that is when the indicator says that the battery is 25% depleted.

I mentioned it to the dealer that I bought the boat from and he gave me some mobo jumbo about how batteries charge and that I shouldn't worry about it.

Is this normal?

Thanks for any help.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,172 Posts
You may have gotten a good deal from your dealer but you are not getting good advice. Most importantly, if you really have two different size batteries (a 200 amp and a 100 amp as bank1) connected in parallel, you have a problem even before considering the charge rate.
Change this first so you have equivalent batteries. Should be easy enough to just switch out the 100 amp o be used as a start battery and connect both 200's in parallel.
Next, can we assume by "generator" you mean alternator?
If so, what is the regulator? Is it set too low? Need more info as the regulator determines the charge rate.
Next, what is your shore charger? Rating? Ability to control bulk charge rate?
Lastly, What meter are you referring to? Is it calibrated? when?

Also, understand that a good regulator or shore charge will sense existing battery state and adjust charge rate accordingly - that said, a fullly charged bank will not have a high rate of charge as you described.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
558 Posts
Most importantly, if you really have two different size batteries (a 200 amp and a 100 amp as bank1) connected in parallel, you have a problem even before considering the charge rate.
Change this first so you have equivalent batteries. Should be easy enough to just switch out the 100 amp o be used as a start battery and connect both 200's in parallel.
There is no problem having two different sized batteries in a single bank. They just need to be the same type - AGM, wet cell, or gel cell.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
558 Posts
I have a new AE 38. I have 3 Batteries. Bank 1 is the house with a 200 amp and a 100 amp. Bank 2 has a 200 amp Engine Battery.

I have a 110 amp generator.

I have a meter that shows how many amps have been used in each bank and how many amps are being either consumed or when the engine is on or I am plugged into shore power, how many amps are going into the battery.

My problem is that i never seem to have much more than 10 amps positive going into either battery bank when I am charging. And unless I run the engine for 3 or 4 hours I can't get the batteries up to even close to 100% charged. And that is when the indicator says that the battery is 25% depleted.

I mentioned it to the dealer that I bought the boat from and he gave me some mobo jumbo about how batteries charge and that I shouldn't worry about it.

Is this normal?

Thanks for any help.
From what you describe you have a battery monitoring system. I think you would be well served by getting a copy of the system's operating instructions and reading it carefully. It's hard to tell what's happening from your description.
 

·
Chesapeake Sailor
Joined
·
579 Posts
My problem is that i never seem to have much more than 10 amps positive going into either battery bank when I am charging. And unless I run the engine for 3 or 4 hours I can't get the batteries up to even close to 100% charged. And that is when the indicator says that the battery is 25% depleted.
The plot of the curve that defines battery acceptance over time becomes extremely flat for the the last few Ah charged. Bringing batteries up to a truly full charge takes an inordinate amount of engine charging because the batteries are not accepting anything like the potential of your alternator: probably as little as 1A for the final few Ah. Plug the boat in to shore power if you have an internal charger and let the charger top off the batteries.

It sounds as if you are charging 75Ah into a house capacity of 300Ah. 10A sounds low for the bulk or absorption phase. If you never discharge the bank greater than 50% (and you shouldn't) then you will likely never see the Alternator (or shore power charger for that matter) supply a very large load to such a relatively small capacity bank.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,172 Posts
There is no problem having two different sized batteries in a single bank. They just need to be the same type - AGM, wet cell, or gel cell.
When you pull a given load from two dissimilar batteries, the effect upon each is different. As an example, if he pulls 100 amps out of a bank consisting of one 200 amp and one 100 amp battery, he lowers the available capacity of each differently - 50 amp from each but 25% of one and 50% of the other all else being equal.
That's the first problem.

The second problem created is in recharging both - the regulator or shore charge doesn't see each battery separately and starts pumping at a rate of the avg which will undercharge the larger battery and over-charge the smaller.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,889 Posts
Whoa...

Can we back up a minute before beginning recommendations?

The Alerion Express 38's new come with gelled house batteries, I believe.

PPrimont: could you please give us some more precise details on your setup?

Specifically:

1. Type of house batteries and AH capacity (I'd be surprised if AE put a 200AH and a 100AH gel battery together for the house bank);

2. Type of start battery and AH capacity (is it really 200AH? sounds like overkill. Is it flooded? AGM? Gelled?);

3. Type of regulator on the alternator (internal or external?);

4. Type, model and capacity of battery charger?

5. How are these wired to the battery switch(es)?

These details are important before one can be reasonably sure of what's going on and/or where to look.

Bill
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
558 Posts
When you pull a given load from two dissimilar batteries, the effect upon each is different. As an example, if he pulls 100 amps out of a bank consisting of one 200 amp and one 100 amp battery, he lowers the available capacity of each differently - 50 amp from each but 25% of one and 50% of the other all else being equal.
That's the first problem.

The second problem created is in recharging both - the regulator or shore charge doesn't see each battery separately and starts pumping at a rate of the avg which will undercharge the larger battery and over-charge the smaller.
We are going to disagree on this one, but since it's not at the core of this thread I'll not go deeper here other than to say that the voltage remains the same in both batteries, so the percent discharge of each is also the same. Charging works the same way.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,172 Posts
Steve
I think it is relevant to the op so I would add this -
think of what happens to resting voltage when you pull 50% out of a battery vs 25%. The only reason both (in his bank) remain at the same voltage is because they are interconnected - the small one is actually competing with the larger.
No matter how you slice it, when you pull amps out of a bank, each battery loses half the amount. When one is smaller than the other, it suffers disproportionately.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
558 Posts
k1vsk - I respectfully disagree with your logic. You don't pull half the amps from each battery. More current flows from the larger battery than the small one. This is regulated by the voltage from each. If the voltage starts to drop in one battery (because it is smaller) it will just supply less current until the voltages are equal again. When charging, if one battery received more current, the voltage would rise in that battery and current going into it would decrease. It's a completely self regulating system.

This is a very important point -> It is true that you should not mix and old battery with a new one, but this is more like mixing types (AGM, wet, or gel) than anything to do with size. As a battery ages the chemistry changes.

There is no difference in a system with one large and one small battery than a system with many batteries. For example with a 6 battery setup, from the prospective of any single battery there is no way to tell that it is connected to 5 others or one that's 5 times larger than it. The entire system acts as one large battery.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
Here's what I've got.

The alternator is a 110A Balmar with a Balmar MC-612 Regulator

There are a total of three batteries:
Two are Lifeline 4D – 210AH, and one Lifeline Group 27 – 100AH. All three are gel batteries.
The battery configuration switch configuration is:
Position “1” – 4D & Group 27 in parallel
Position “2” – 4D

The monitor is a Xantrex Link 20

I don't have the info on the AC charger at this time. But I don't think that is important since I'm experiencing the same conditions.

Next time at the boat I am going to check the Link 20 configuration to be sure it was set properly in the first place.

Thanks for everyone's comments. Of course there are many opinions. I'll sort them out and see what happens.

Peter
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,172 Posts
Peter
The first thing you should check is the regulator output setting to see if measured voltage is consistent and do so when the batteries are NOT fully charged.
Additionally, make sure the Link20 rate is properly set and calibrated.

Regardless of the varying opinions with respect to battery configuration between Steve and me, no one can contest the over-riding benefit to combine the two larger batteries as a large house bank. Having a separate 200 amp start battery is overkill when compared with your present 300 amp "Position 1" house bank .

The larger the house bank, the smaller the discharge rate resulting in prolonging the life of the batteries.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
558 Posts
The manual for your motor should give you the specs for the required starting battery. The group 27 battery is probably sufficient. I agree that rewiring the system so the group 27 is your starting battery and the the two 4Ds are your house battery makes sense. You don't want two house banks, just one large one with an simple on/off switch. Use your 1,2,all, off switch as an interconnect so you can start from the house bank if needed. There are many ways to set up your batteries, but this is a common, modern approach.

Following the steps in the Link 20 manual for battery capacity testing should give you an idea of the health of your batteries. If the actual capacity is was off from the advertised capacity you batteries are on their way out.
 

·
Chesapeake Sailor
Joined
·
579 Posts
Peter,

I'll bet those batteries are AGM (absorbed glass mat [sometimes material]). Very good batteries btw.

I don't think Lifeline makes gells.

Other than the odd grouping of house batteries - I'll bet there is nothing wrong with your system. I agree with your salesman!

Wayne
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,889 Posts
Peter,

OK, now we're getting somewhere.

First, I agree that it's very likely your Lifeline batteries are AGMs, not gelled cell batteries.

I also agree that the grouping is rather strange, and it would be beneficial at some point to connect the two 4Ds together and run them as a single 420AH house battery bank, and to use the 100AH battery for starting.

You didn't mention a battery combiner or echo charge device. How is the alternator connected?

Since you already have a 1-2-Both-Off switch, an easy way to improve the setup would be:

1. Wire both 4Ds together in parallel, and connect this bank to position #1 on the battery switch.

2. Wire the 100AH battery to it's own ON-OFF switch and to the start solenoid.

3. Run a cable from the the new ON-OFF switch to position #2 on the battery switch.

4. Install an EchoCharge or DuoCharge device, connected between the house bank and the start battery. This device is completely automatic, and bleeds some of the charge off the house batteries to keep the start battery charged.

5. Connect the output of the Balmar 110A alternator -- and all other onboard charging sources (battery charger, generator, wind, solar, etc.) to the house battery bank.

6. Leave the switch in the #1 position. The "BOTH" position would be only for those very rare times when the start battery is depleted and you want to start from the house batteries.

Now, about the original question re: charging amperage.

There may or may not be something amiss. AGMs can absorb A LOT of amperage...all your 110A alternator can throw at them...and more. The MC612 controls how much amperage is going to the batteries, based on its internal charging algorithm ("program") and upon external factors such as battery voltage, battery temperature, and alternator temperature (assuming these sensors are fitted).

It's really a quite sophisticated system, and works beautifully once set up correctly. There are some potential bug-a-boos, though.

In order for things to work correctly, you need:

1. the correct program chosen in the MC-612 (i.e., PO4 AGL);
2. all sensors correctly connected and working properly;
3. adequate size wiring;
4. clean, tight connections; and
5. alternator belt tensioned properly and not slipping.

The best way to easily check re: output is probably to take the boat out, drain the house batteries to about 50% charged state (about 12.3VDC with NO LOAD and NO CHARGE after sitting for several hours...as measured with a reliable multimeter AT THE BATTERY TERMINALS).

Then, when you start the engine, after 40 seconds or so you should see the amperage ramp up to somewhere over 80. If you see this, then the system would seem to be basically OK. However, if you only see 10A or so, something is definitely wrong.

Note that temperature sensors can give improper readings. If you suspect a bad temp sensor, just pull it's connector off the MC-612 and see what happens.

Finally, don't worry about the readings you get from the battery monitor -- at least not until you know it's been properly calibrated and you've lived with it awhile. These things can be good, but they can also give very misleading information.

Sorry to be so long-winded. Hope this helps a bit.

Bill
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top